Luke McLaughlin 

Italy 0-17 Scotland: Six Nations 2020 – as it happened

Stuart Hogg’s stunning first-half try set Scotland on the way to their first victory of the Six Nations, while Italy disappointingly failed to register a point for the second time in three matches
  
  

Adam Hastings celebrates after scoring Scotland’s third try.
Adam Hastings celebrates after scoring Scotland’s third try. Photograph: Dan Mullan/Getty Images

If you missed it, here’s that match report again:

So it’s the same old story for Italy. Worryingly, they have now been ‘nilled’ twice in three matches in 2020. They’ve played some good stuff, they are trying to play in the right way and produce entertaining rugby, but just haven’t been able to build any real momentum in any of their three games in this tournament so far.

For Scotland, there was some pressure following two defeats against Ireland and England, and they delivered when it counted - particularly Stuart Hogg with that eye-catching first-half score that felt like the decisive moment of the match.

It was far from a thrilling spectacle, in truth, but Scotland got the job done. With Ireland and England to come, Italy are surely destined for another wooden spoon. I will see you next time - join Lee Calvert for Wales v France right here!

Italy remaining fixtures:

7 Mar v Ireland (A)
14 Mar v England (H)

Scotland remaining fixtures:

8 Mar v France (H)
14 Mar v Wales (A)

Wales v France is coming up very shortly - it should be a cracker, and Lee Calvert will be MBM-ing it here for all it’s worth:

A match report for you, from William Pickworth:

Scotland coach Gregor Townsend speaks: “A tough win, we had to tough it out at times ... they are a tough team and they can stretch your defence ... our attack didn’t flow as well as we’d have liked. The back row was very good, they knew it was a big challenge, and they were everywhere.

“It’s great that he [Hogg] got a win, and scored a world-class try like that. It’s a bit frustrating not to get the bonus point but to score three scores to nil, against a team that’s been a difficult opponent for us, is pleasing.”

Updated

Scotland had 67 % of territory, which seems a fair reflection of how it went. Italy made 192 tackles to Scotland’s 190, which is slightly surprising, it felt like Scotland had most of the tackling to do.

Stuart Hogg speaks to ITV: “We’re delighted with that, we came here to do a job, and we’ve done exactly that ... I’m proud of the boys, it was a huge effort and we came away with an important win.”

On the battle at the breakdown: “We challenged our boys to get us on the front foot ... you can see that with Hamish Watson getting the man of the match.”

“A huge part of the game now is the kicking game ... we want to be playing with that kind of defence, thankfully it opened up and I scored in the corner. I wasn’t making a mess of that one, I can assure you.”

That’s boss, Hogg.

On ITV, Sir Ian McGeechan is impressed with elements of Scotland’s game: “The discipline, the patience and the work without the ball. Last year, they were attacking at will, but losing. It was the patience, the discipline, the hard work collectively, for each other. Where they were better I felt is that they started to bring players around the ruck [in attack]. The discipline and patience in them was clear today.”

Gareth Thomas: “Italy were unbelievably naive in defence.”

Maggie Alphonsi: “It was Scotland’s defensive speed out of the line that stopped Italy making any progress, and even drove them back.”

Updated

Full-time! Italy 0-17 Scotland

All over. Italy will be gutted that they could not even muster a score of any kind for their home fans to cheer. Once again, they had their moments, and once again, they failed to convert some nice attacking phases into pressure for their opponents on the scoreboard.

The turnover count was terrifying - much as England got on top in the breakdown at Murrayfield a couple of weeks ago, Scotland firmly exerted their dominance at the breakdown in Rome today, and that allowed their back line to make an impact in a way their Italian counterparts never could.

Stuart Hogg will be thrilled with that stunning first-half try, which was added to by second-half scores by Harris and Hastings. It’s his first win as Scotland captain. They delivered when it counted and they had to defend very strongly for most of that match. It was no picnic.

Updated

80 min: One last go for Italy ... No-one would begrudge them a score here.

Updated

Try! 79 min: Italy 0-17 Scotland (Hastings)

Counterattack down the blind side for Scotland, no-one at home for Italy, and Hastings runs the ball in. That was the 21st turnover of the match by Scotland. They are home and dry. The conversion is drop-kicked by the try scorer, saving a few seconds, so they can try and grab a very late bonus point.

Updated

78 min: Italy keep trying, Scotland keep tackling. Licata and Minozzi link up well down the left, but then the ball is spilled, and Townsend’s men can break into space on their own left wing.

Updated

75 min: Italy have a scrum near halfway. But Scotland’s defensive shape looks just fine. The ball is slow for the hosts, and they cannot seem to make any inroads. Scotland have the extra man, of course, so that’s another thing in their favour.

For Scottish fans in Rome, thoughts are turning to tonight’s restaurant reservation ...

Updated

73 min: Italy have all the ingredients to be a top team, but they don’t seem to be able to knit it all together for long enough. Scotland have made 133 tackles - they have been kept very busy - but increasingly look to have this one wrapped up.

70 min: Yellow card! Federico Zani (Italy)

Italy will be a man down for the final 10 minutes. That was the last thing they needed ... The original penalty was for a high tackle by Scotland but on replay, Zani’s tip tackle saw the penalty reversed. A hammer blow for Italy’s chances of getting back into this in the last throes of this match.

Updated

69 min: Italy move through a few phases of possession around halfway. Scotland’s tackling remains fierce. Palazzani floats a pass out left, but it’s taken back for a penalty for an illegal tackle by Scotland. The TMO is having a look at this ... and in fact it looks like Federico Zani is going to get a yellow card. Gilchrist and McGuigan are on for Scotland.

Updated

67 min: And just like that, Hogg gives a hand to Italy with an over-egged kick. The Azzurri will have a line-out, but with a little over 10 minutes remaining, they need to get busy and get themselves on the scoreboard.

66 min: That first-half try by Stuart Hogg is looking more and more like the decisive moment in this match. It put Scotland ahead on the scoreboard and psychologically allowed them to shake off any negativity from the previous rounds ... Hogg said they believed in their ability, and so far, they have backed those words up with performance. Especially Hogg himself.

63 min: As we move into the final quarter, Scotland are looking stronger and stronger. They are carrying into contact with plenty of conviction and Italy are struggling to find any kind of foothold now - although they are not rolling over and continuing to tackle as if for their lives.

61 min: The second Scotland try, courtesy of ITV Rugby’s Twitter:

Updated

60 min: Fraser Brown on for Scotland, McInally goes off.

59 min: Danilo Fischetti and Guglielmo Palazzani come on for the hosts, in the front row and at scrum-half, respectively. This one is slipping away from them.

Updated

58 min: Fine work to turn defence into attack by Scotland. They spoil Italian ball, turn it over and Kinghorn picks the ball up and sprints half the length of the pitch down the left wing. The Italian scramble defence is excellent again, however, and it stays a 10-point game.

55 min: Changes for Scotland. Dell and Nel on in the front row. Matt Fagerson is on too.

Is this going to be Italy’s second ‘zero’ of the Six Nations? The fans will be praying to get on the board, as will the players. They deserve something from this, they have played the right way.

Updated

54 min: A break in play for an Italian injury. The prop Zilocchi, who was pulled off by Franco Smith in the first half, is back on the field. Riccioni leaves the field on a buggy and looks badly hurt. We wish him well.

Updated

53 min: Breathless, brilliant stuff now. Scotland warm to their task and attack into space straight down the middle with Hastings. The ball is lost when he tries to off-load, though, and Italy immediately roar down to the other end thanks to a lovely run by Hayward. Then it’s with Minozzi and Bellini - the crowd are on their feet - Polledri makes a burst for the line too - but the Scotland defenders manage to scramble and they repel the danger. Again, Italy just couldn’t get numbers to the breakdown quick enough, or recycle the ball efficiently enough, to make the decisive move over the try line.

Updated

50 min: Italy aren’t done yet. They get on top at the latest scrum, and celebrate like they’ve scored a try. Riccioni shouts a few confrontational words at his opposite number after the Azzurri force a free-kick which they kick for touch. From the resulting attack, Luca Bigi spills the ball forward and Scotland can clear.

Updated

Try! 47 min: Italy 0-10 Scotland (Harris)

They are over! That was a really patient, well-worked score as Scotland gradually ground the Italian defence down. Watson and Ritchie made a huge shove to virtually over the line, it was recycled and spun to the right, and Harris did well to dive over despite the attentions of a tackler. Hastings misses the conversion, and it’s 10-0.

Updated

46 min: Scotland batter away on the try line and there is some brilliant last-ditch defending from Italy ... Watson and Ritchie join forces to try and smash over, and now it’s a try!

Updated

44 min: Dean Budd and Giovanni Licata on for Italy. The home crowd are still making plenty of noise - how they’d love to see their team get over the try line. At the moment, it’s all about defence for the Azzurri with Scotland camped in the Italian 22.

Updated

41 min: Scotland begin the second half with attacking intent, moving through a few phases around the Italian 22. Then there is a decisive burst by Watson, who finds Bradbury, and he offers up the ball to Ritchie - but Polledri does enough to put him off and he knocks on with the try line beckoning ... It seems Ritchie is complaining that he was tackled before he took the pass, but the ref isn’t having it. From the resulting play, Ritchie turns the ball over again, the 12th time Italy have given up possession at the breakdown.

Updated

Second-half kick-off!

Hastings kicks off for Scotland. Here we go - can Italy find their first victory for five years, and their first at home in seven years?

Updated

Half-time thoughts from the ITV pundits:

Sir Ian McGeechan: “Defensively Scotland have scrambled well, but Townsend will be a bit frustrated with what’s happening in the 22 ... they are very narrow and making it easy to defend.”

Gareth Thomas: “It [the try] was worth waiting for ... what’s great about a good full-back is that they see opportunities really early, he’s got a forward in front of him ... [No 13] Luca Morisi is defending no-one and Hogg goes through the gap.”

Maggie Alphonsi: “This game’s been dominated by the breakdown area and Scotland have turned the ball over 11 times.”

Thomas also spoke of Hogg exorcising demons with that try - but the match isn’t won yet ...

Updated

Half-time! Italy 0-5 Scotland

It’s low-scoring, but it’s a fine contest. Scotland lead thanks to a sensational try by their captain Stuart Hogg. Italy have played with attacking intent, and asked some very serious questions of the visiting defence - but they are empty-handed so far. Franco Smith should tell his men to keep doing what they are doing, because Scotland may not be able to contain them for 80 minutes playing like that ...

What do you think of the match so far? Fire over an email or a tweet!

Updated

40 min: Watson feeds Bradbury, who tries to bash his way through a couple of tackles. Then it’s Sam Johnson bursting into contact and Scotland are into the Italian 22! Hogg makes another dart, but then it’s knocked on by a team-mate, and it’s half-time.

Updated

39 min: Allan strikes the ball beautifully off the tee, but hits the left-hand post! Italy look likely to head in at the break scoreless, but they are playing some decent stuff. It’s the cutting edge they need to find against an impressive Scottish defensive effort so far.

Updated

37 min: More space for Italy’s back-line! Hayward bursts right with lots of space to run into, then feeds Bellini who is running a line back in towards the posts. Scottish hands manage to rip the ball away at the resulting breakdown, though, and the danger is clear again. But now Italy have a penalty and will kick for the posts.

Updated

35 min: Now there is some strong work over the ball by Polledri, who celebrates after winning a penalty, burrowing away strongly for possession while staying on his feet. Into the final five minutes and it looks like this match is going to be a nervy affair into the second half. The teams look well matched.

Updated

33 min: Referee O’Keeffe gives both captains a talking-to about maintaining the space between them at line-out time. Italy now do well to turn over Scottish possession on their own 22-metre line, and again look to run the ball. It’s moved right and Bellini is released into space, but he is forced into touch by a good tackle by Kinghorn. If Italy keep asking these questions, you fancy they will break through at some point and get over the try line.

Updated

32 min: Another penalty at the breakdown, forced by Watson. Great work at the tackle area by Townsend’s men.

29 min: Disallowed try!

There is a TMO check for a forward pass after what looks a nice Scottish score, and it’s ruled out ... It was a wonderful move down the left from the visitors, with Watson is penalised for an off-load inside that went forward.

Meanwhile, the 22-year-old tight-head prop Marco Riccioni comes on for Giosuè Zilocchi, who was having a torrid time in the scrums.

Updated

27 min: Italy have a line-out just over halfway. They win it, but the fly-half Allan fumbles the ball after a brief maul, but he’s lucky that it goes backwards.

Now there’s a replay of Hogg’s try - the celebrations were passionate from him and the team, as you’d expect after a tough start to the campaign. The way Hogg beat Italy full-back Jayden Hayward was sensational, and coach Townsend will want to see plenty more of that.

Updated

Try! 23 min: Italy 0-5 Scotland (Hogg)

Electric pace! Brilliant try! And it’s the Scotland captain who delivers. After Scotland win possession thanks to that errant off-load by Polledri, captain Hogg grabs the ball in midfield. He drifts to the right, switches on the after-burners after a side-step, beats a couple of would-be tacklers, and burns over in the corner. Brilliant try and a very welcome one from the Scotland captain’s point of view. Hastings misses a tough conversion. For all their good early work, Italy find themselves trailing in Rome. That of course is Scotland’s first try of the tournament.

Updated

22 min: Polledri storms towards the Scottish try line now, and tries to off-load, but only finds Hastings ...

21 min: Italy surge forward into the right-hand corner - but Scotland’s work at the breakdown is very good again, and they effect another good turnover. However Scotland are working overtime in defence.

Updated

20 min: A quarter of the match gone, and it’s scoreless so far, but both teams are showing a willingness to attack and keep the ball in hand. It’s been decent, if not exactly scintillating so far. Now Minozzi finds a bit of space on the wing, and goes searching for his own chip down the left ...

Updated

17 min: Scotland deal with the danger well and can clear for touch, relieving a bit of pressure. Still no score, but Italy are having the best of it at the moment. But now Scotland turn it over!

“The set-piece is quite a mess,” says Bortolami of Italy on commentary.

Updated

14 min: Hamish Watson complains to the referee that the Italians are messing around with their numbers at the line-outs. Meanwhile, Italy kick for the corner, they get the line-out right - Scotland concede a penalty, the ref has a word with the visitors about how they are using their jumpers at the line-outs. Italy kick for the corner again - tonnes of pressure on Townsend’s team right now.

Updated

13 min: Bellini makes a brilliant burst straight through the middle! The crowd are on their feet, and the visitors are defending desperately. Bellini does well to run with the ball in two hands, keeping his options open. He skips inside and finds Hayward in the Scottish 22. The ball is then moved left and it’s forced out into touch. Real danger and attacking intent from Italy, though, which we expected.

Updated

12 min: Scotland move it through the hands around halfway. Watson makes a strong burst over the gain line. But Italy counterattack!

9 min: A horrendous miss off the tee by Hastings - that is a very easy kick inside the Italian 22, but he sends it right. It’s still 0-0. Frustration for Scotland, even if they are well on top in the scrums so far.

Updated

8 min: Yet another scrum after that knock-on by Bradbury - and again Scotland get the penalty! The visitors are well on top at scrum time. Hastings will kick for goal.

Updated

7 min: A fine attacking platform for Scotland, for the first time, who run the ball to within a metre of two of the Italian line on the left wing. Hogg has a dart from close range. But then it’s a mistake by Bradbury as Scotland look to go again - he knocks on, after a couple of big hits from Italy and the pressure is relieved. Scoreless so far.

Updated

5 min: Italy win a free-kick now, in Scotland’s half, and opt to take a scrum. The home crowd are making plenty of noise. But the scrum collapses, and the decision goes against Italy. Giosuè Zilocchi is on the back foot against Fagerson so far.

Updated

3 min: We’ve had two scrums inside the first three minutes and not a huge amount else. Ben O’Keeffe the referee lays down the law - and gives the first scrum penalty to Italy, for Zander Fagerson dropping the bind.

Updated

1 min: A quick line-out for Italy following a clearing kick by Scotland, but a mistake leads to a scrum put-in for Scotland on halfway. There is immediately a close-up of Smith shaking his head up in the stand.

Updated

First-half kick-off!

We are under way - Tommaso Allan kicks off for Italy.

Updated

The teams are out on the pitch at a sun-soaked Stadio Olimpico and it’s time for the anthems. “Flower of Scotland” first.

Less than 10 minutes until kick off in Rome.

Time to squeeze in Paul Rees on England’s part-time No 8 Tom Curry?

Italy’s pack prepare to get the shove on against Scotland:

Updated

Scotland coach Gregor Townsend speaks on ITV: “We need to impose our game on the opposition. They are passing the ball more, running the ball more - they are built to attack, to move the opposition around. There’s no excuses today, because of the weather ... the mental side of the game is really important every time you play, you’ve got to deal with the circumstances, and I believe out players will do that today.”

And Italy coach Franco Smith: “Our preparation went well ... in a new environment it always takes a bit of time ... we are definitely better prepared [than for the first two rounds]. We need to get the breakdown right, Scotland want to slow us down at the breakdown. We’ll need to be accurate there. We want to improve, we want to prove to people we belong in this competition. We’ve worked really hard in the last four weeks and we want to show that today.”

Updated

Before England v Ireland there is Wales v France later today - AKA Wales v Shaun Edwards. Here is Paul Rees:

Updated

And here is rugby correspondent Robert Kitson on why England badly need a win against Andy Farrell’s Ireland ...

Some pre-match reading from our columnist Ugo Monye, previewing Ireland’s trip to Twickenham tomorrow:

Updated

Some pre-match quotes from Italy coach Franco Smith here, courtesy of the official Six Nations website: “We showed improvements against France. We want to produce an impressive performance in front of our fans at the Stadio Olimpico, showing everyone our game and our true potential.

“Each game is a chance to increase our skills, we have been working together for a month to build our identity, our DNA. It is the most important aspect we are focused on. We think about us and what we have to do.”

Updated

McGeechan with a few thoughts on Scotland fly-half Adam Hastings: “Today more than anything, with Johnson and Harris in the centres, I hope he runs ... he’s got good feet ... I could see him really go at the defence, with people like Johnson on his shoulder, who is a really good support player.”

Don’t forget, you can drop me a line on email or on Twitter with any thoughts on today’s match. If you are following from some far-flung corner of the globe, do get in touch.

Conditions-wise, it really is a different world for the Scotland players today. Sunny and 17C. Both teams like to run the ball - in theory, we may well be in for a highly entertaining encounter.

Updated

“The only pressure is the pressure we put on ourselves,” Scotland captain Hogg said this week. “We believe in our collective ability to win rugby matches ... everything else is irrelevant.”

Italy will no doubt be looking to exert some pressure of their own. “I’m very confident,” now says pundit Marco Bortolami on ITV, speaking to Gabriel Clarke. “I think this team is ready to deliver a big performance. The key thing is to earn the right to play wide. The front five need to create go-forward for the backs.”

Kick-off is coming up at 2.15pm GMT.

Updated

The sun is out in Rome; it’s a far cry from the way Storm Ciara battered Murrayfield a couple of weeks back. ITV pundit Sir Ian McGeechan says that means the visitors need to deliver some decent rugby this afternoon: “For Scotland, no excuses,” McGeechan says. “In the conditions today, you’d want to see the kind of high-tempo game that they can play.

“The back rows will be important. Who wins the breakdowns, who wins the front-foot ball ... that could well be the difference,” McGeechan adds.

Updated

Teams

Franco Smith sticks with the same selection that impressed at times during their defeat in Paris. (Alessandro Zanni was injured in the warm-up at Stade de France, and was replaced by Dean Budd, but he is is ready to go today.)

Italy XV: 15. Jayden Hayward, 14. Mattia Bellini, 13. Luca Morisi, 12. Carlo Canna, 11. Matteo Minozzi, 10. Tommaso Allan, 9. Callum Braley, 1. Andrea Lovotti, 2. Luca Bigi (c), 3. Giosuè Zilocchi, 4. Alessandro Zanni, 5. Niccolò Cannone, 6. Jake Polledri, 7. Sebastian Negri, 8. Abraham Steyn.

Replacements: 16. Federico Zani, 17. Danilo Fischetti, 18. Marco Riccioni, 19. Marco Lazzaroni, 20. Dean Budd, 21. Giovanni Licata, 22. Guglielmo Palazzani, 23. Giulio Bisegni.

Gregor Townsend makes three changes for Scotland. Gloucester’s Chris Harris comes in for Huw Jones at outside centre, Ben Toolis replaces the injured Jonny Gray at lock, and Stuart McInally comes in for Fraser Brown at hooker.

Scotland XV: 15. Stuart Hogg (c), 14. Sean Maitland, 13. Chris Harris, 12. Sam Johnson, 11. Blair Kinghorn, 10. Adam Hastings, 9. Ali Price, 1. Rory Sutherland, 2. Stuart McInally), 3. Zander Fagerson, 4. Ben Toolis, 5. Scott Cummings, 6. Jamie Ritchie, 7. Hamish Watson, 8. Magnus Bradbury.

Replacements: 16. Fraser Brown, 17. Allan Dell, 18. Willem Nel, 19. Grant Gilchrist, 20. Matt Fagerson, 21. George Horne, 22. Rory Hutchinson, 23. Byron McGuigan.

Updated

Preamble

Who will be in possession of ‘il cucchiaio di legno’ come the middle of next month?

The last time Italy managed to avoid the wooden spoon was five years ago, when they narrowly, stirringly defeated Scotland at Murrayfield. And that, as you probably know, is the last time the Azzurri won a Six Nations match.

There are reasons to be cheerful. From an attacking point of view, they weren’t as bad as the 42-0 scoreline in the opener against Wales suggests. And as their coach Franco Smith rightly says Italy showed improvement in Paris two weeks ago, successfully building momentum in attack and achieving the kind of continuity that has generally eluded them at European rugby’s top table. Wasps’ Marco Minozzi has been a constant running threat and fly-half Tommaso Allan has shown some lovely touches at times.

Coaches generally trot out the necessary platitudes about treating each opponent and each match just the same, but Smith and his players know this is by far their best chance of getting a ‘W’ on the board in this tournament. Expect them to start fast.

As for the visitors, Scotland’s year so far has been punctuated by Stuart Hogg’s two horror moments in narrow defeats by Ireland and England - plus head coach Gregor Townsend’s public falling out with Finn Russell, who remains out in the cold. It’s hardly been a happy campaign for them so far but victory in Rome today will see some semblance of order restored. Lose, and the sausages on social media are sure to be out in force.

Scottish captain Hogg got back on his horse with Exeter to stunning effect a few days ago. A few more moments of magic like this, and Hogg and his men will be heading home with a first win on the board. Team news to follow ...

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*