So there you have it, Round 2 of the 2020 Six Nations is done and dusted. Wales followed up their dominant demolition of Italy with a one-sided defeat in Dublin, while England extinguished their Parisian pain with a powerful win over Scotland at a rain and wind-lashed Murrayfield.
France made it two from two today in Paris, in a quintessentially French stop-start performance, and Italy lost yet again - but they showed much, much more than they did in Round 1 against Wales and have plenty of plus-points to take into their next match against Scotland. France go to Wales next, while England host Ireland at Twickenham.
Table-wise, France and Ireland are level on nine points, Wales and England are both on five, Scotland are on two and Italy are on zero. The Six Nations takes a break next weekend, but we will be back for more very soon. Thanks for reading - and see you next time.
Updated
Match report!
Tommaso Allan, the Italy fly-half: “The wind is a bit swirly, but that’s how it is for both teams ... We improved our performance compared to last week, today we played a bit more attacking, but we still need a bit more patience when we get in the opposition 22 ... We are trying to compete every single game, Scotland have had two losses, so that will be a tough game in Rome.”
Italy captain Luca Bigi: “We improved our performance, we showed how strong we can be, we scored a try in the last minute which shows we never give up ... I’m very proud to be part of this team, the guys showed big things on the pitch today. It was a tough week [in training] because we conceded too many turnovers at the breakdown last week.”
La victoire et le bonus!
Travail accompli, you could say.
🇫🇷🇮🇹 La 𝐯𝐢𝐜𝐭𝐨𝐢𝐫𝐞 et le 𝐛𝐨𝐧𝐮𝐬 ! Les Bleus gagnent leur 2e match dans ce tournoi des #SixNations 2020 ! 𝐁𝐫𝐚𝐯𝐨 les garçons ! 👏 #XVdeFrance #NeFaisonsXV #FRAITA pic.twitter.com/nFvSjEdqkQ
— France Rugby (@FranceRugby) February 9, 2020
France second row Paul Willemse speaks to the BBC out on the pitch: “We got the bonus point so we are happy, but there are a lot of errors we made, especially with our discipline, so we need to fix that as soon as possible. It’s not normal for us to have [concede] all those penalties, but we’ll definitely focus on that in the weeks to come.
“The atmosphere has been great in our team, we have a lot of young guys who are just starting in the French team ... it’s about getting together and building our own history.”
Full-time! France 35-22 Italy
All over. France stay on course with two wins from two. They were excellent at times and not so excellent at others. Will they fancy their chances of going to Wales and winning on this form? It’s a possibility but they need to sharpen up. Italy did very well for the most part, they defended much better, and provided a real threat in attack with three tries. There are encouraging signs there for coach Franco Smith - but much like the Wales game they fell a long way behind in the first 20. At least on this occasion they established a foothold in the match, and posed some real problems for their opponents.
Updated
Try! 80 min: France 35-22 Italy (Mattia Bellini)
Italy deserve that and it’s a really classy try. Hayward makes a break and finds Mattia Bellini outside him, and he finishes smartly. Hayward had an option inside, and it looked at first glance like going outside might have been the wrong option. But they get a morale-boosting try.
Updated
78 min: Now Palazzani takes a quick tap in midfield for Italy. The Azzurri pour forward, but it’s lost, and a French boot belts the ball deep, back into enemy territory. The French fans are giving ‘La Marseillaise’ another outing as the clock ticks down. Party time in Paris.
77 min: France roar forward again, into the Italian 22, with a lovely line by No 8 Alldritt busting through the defensive line and getting his team right on the front foot. Bellini puts in a good tackle though and then Italy manage to turn it over. Exciting times! France fell asleep for much of the second half but they are finishing strongly. They will be equal with Ireland on nine points at the top of the Six Nations table after this.
Updated
Try! 74 min: France 35-17 Italy (Baptiste Serin)
What a magnificent individual try by the replacement scrum-half. He takes a quick tap penalty, surges beyond a few defenders who aren’t allowed to touch him, puts in a smart little grubber kick, shows considerable pace to run on to it beyond the last line of Italian defence, and dives over to touch down. Jalibert converts. That was the score of the match.
Updated
73 min: Wise words ... Edwards may also call on his English vocab, because the French guys will definitely be familiar with a few of the more common ones.
@LukeMcLaughlin whatever happens in the next 10 minutes, I guess the French team are going to find out how many French expletives Shaun Edwards knows
— 10ep (@10ep1) February 9, 2020
The TV director takes a few seconds to focus on those fans dressed as slices of pizza. They are clearly having a great day!
Updated
70 min: Hayward pumps a high kick into French territory. It seems to be a little too long and Ntamack looks well set to claim it, but he drops it and knocks it forward. Horrible error. Italy grab it back, and win a penalty, and have another chance to put France under more pressure ...
Ntamack is hauled off after a mixed day, Matthieu Jalibert comes on at No 10.
Updated
68 min: France manage to turn the ball over from Italy’s line-out ball now. “A real momentum-killer,” observes Davies. France have a scrum now, on their own 22.
Try! 65 min: France 28-17 Italy (Federico Zani)
France can’t get organised and Zani manages to press the ball down at the base of a post following a really good driving maul. Allan slots the conversion. Well done again Italy. If France manage to lose this game it would be astonishing, really.
Updated
64 min: Italy come again. They kick a penalty to the corner and try a driving maul, and they make good ground.
62 min: Jefferson Poirot, Demba Bamba and Cameron Woki are all on for France. Mauvaka and Serin too. Guglielmo Palazzani is on at scrum-half for Italy and Marco Riccioni is on, too.
Updated
Try! 59 min: France 28-10 Italy (Romain Ntamack)
Lovely, pacy rugby from France for the first time in a while. Dupont seizes the ball off the back of a maul and finds numbers on his left shoulder. Ntamack glides beyond the defensive cover and dives over. It’s another try and surely game over? French levels dropped considerably in the third quarter, but that is better, and it’s a winning bonus point. Ntamack fluffs the conversion after his own try.
Updated
58 min: Again it’s good stuff from Italy, Allan claiming a high ball and finding numbers in space on the left. Minozzi then skips beyond a tackle and off-loads on his inside, but Italy immediately concede a penalty for holding on at the resulting ruck, won by Taofifenua.
Updated
56 min: France’s defence coach Shaun Edwards is pictured up in the stands. His arms are firmly folded, and he doesn’t look too happy. France have become a bit sloppy, in truth. The French fans have accordingly gone quiet. Italy have been the better team for the past 15 minutes.
Updated
55 min: Allan pulls a penalty attempt wide for Italy from close range. A shame, if we want to see a grandstand finish.
“He can’t be missing from there, I don’t care how bad the wind is,” says O’Connell.
“Said the second row ...” counters Eddie Butler.
Updated
52 min: Giovanni Licata and Danilo Fischetti come on for Italy, Andrea Lovotti and Luca Bigi go off. Hayward now puts in an excellent kick deep into French territory. If Italy can find the next score, we’ve got an enthralling final 28 minutes on our hands.
Updated
50 min: Italy turn the ball over from a French line-out. Polledri powers through a tackle and the ball is then moved to the left. Italy are playing some very decent rugby here and are keeping the French crowd pretty quiet for the most part. They are starting to play with that much-needed continuity at times, and it’s good to see.
Updated
47 min: Italy cough up a penalty for not rolling away. Ntamack kicks for touch and they’ll have a very decent spot for a line-out, just inside the Italian 22. They choose to maul it, then spin it right, and there is lots more defending to do for Italy. Romain Taofifenua has come on in the second row in place of Paul Willemse for France.
Updated
43 min: More good signs for the Italians. Jayden Hayward makes a confident catch from a high ball, the ball is recycled to the left, and Dean Budd is freed to make a rampaging run into space on the touchline, behind the vast majority of the defensive cover. The ball is then worked all the way over to the other side of the pitch and it needs a strong French tackle in the corner on Bellini, by Bouthier, to stop another try for the visitors. France are vulnerable at times, and will not feel secure even with a 13-point lead.
Updated
41 min: Italy’s No 6 Jake Polledri does very well to grab a loose ball at the back of a ruck near halfway. Italy work it left and Minozzi sprints into space, down the touchline. He tries a little kick inside but he has a foot in touch.
Updated
Second half kick-off!
Can Italy find a way to make a real game of this? Let’s find out. The score is 23-10 in France’s favour.
Updated
Thomas Castaignède assesses France’s first-half display: “We started well, we were winning the collisions ... but then we didn’t seem to know what we wanted to do. As long as we win the collisions, and make some offloads, we look dangerous.”
Ex-Italy player Luke McLean: “It looked like it might be a big grim after 20 minutes, I thought it was going to be the same as the Wales game ... but Italy changed tactics, and they were actually quite clinical when they got chances.”
Updated
Half-time! France 23-10 Italy
A good half of rugby. France appeared to be ‘doing a Wales’ and getting ready to run away with it completely, but Italy rallied impressively, before leaking another try right at the end of the half.
Try! 39 min: France 23-10 Italy (Grégory Alldritt)
More pressure, more points. The French decision to pass up that earlier kick for goal is fully justified. France have options all over the place, and a wonderful long, looping pass by Dupont finds the No 8 Grégory Alldritt in tonnes of space on the left, and he runs it in. Lovely vision by Dupont and Les Bleus are back in control. Ntamack converts, although in bizarre fashion. He sends the kick to the left, it smacks off the post, rebounds across to the other post, hits that, and goes over for the two points. What are the chances?
Updated
36 min: Second row Willemse is released by Ollivon and embarks on a powerful run down the middle, into the Italian 22, and then returns the favour for his scrum-half Dupont with an excellent off-load. The Italian defence is stretched all over the place but they manage to repel the danger for now. Now France pass up the chance for a penalty and kick for the corner.
34 min: Italy launch another excellent attack with good hands down the left wing, with Minozzi getting involved once again. It culminates in a scrum for the visitors.
“They’ve got no continuity,” remarks Jonathan Davies on commentary, of the Italians, and he is quite right. They are making a game of it though.
Updated
Penalty! 32 min: France 16-10 Italy (Romain Ntamack)
A little more daylight on the scoreboard for the hosts. Italian indiscipline is punished.
Updated
32 min: Now Italy are punished for going off their feet at a ruck, with the defence back under plenty of pressure following a kick straight into touch by Allan. There was a crash ball by Arthur Vincent as France neared the Italian line.
Penalty! 29 min: France 13-10 Italy (Tommaso Allan)
You love to see it. Well, you do if you are neutral hoping for a nice close match. Italy storm back into the contest, after France appeared to be cruising with those two early tries.
Updated
29 min: Allan now has a kick at goal from 35 metres. He can bring his team within three here ...
Try! 24 min: France 13-7 Italy (Matteo Minozzi)
It’s only taken 104 minutes of rugby, but Italy are on the board in the 2020 Six Nations! And it’s a well-worked score too - Minozzi dives over in the corner after he’s fed by a fine pass by Jayden Hayward. Teddy Thomas over-committed in the French defence and was punished, after Italy built pressure exceptionally well. It was good work by Tommaso Allan the fly-half too. Allan then nails the kick, an absolutely beautiful strike. Well done Italy. Chapeau, as they say in Paris.
Updated
22 min: Breaking: Italy are in the French half! It’s scrum put-in for the Azzurri on the French 22. Now they work through some phases in possession rather nicely. Allan makes a half-break towards the left corner. Then they spin it right and France are having to make tackle after tackle. And Minozzi is in!!!
Updated
Try! 18 min: France 13-0 Italy (Charles Ollivon)
More pressure, and another try, which was created by a lovely blend of skill and pace from Dupont, and then some tremendously powerful forward play by this French pack, who force their way over in the left-hand corner. The skipper gets the ball down. Ntamack hits the crossbar with an excellent conversion attempt which just doesn’t quite have the legs. The crowd have woken up a bit. Italy need to wake up too ... even if, in fairness, they defended pretty resolutely there with some big hits, but were just worn down.
Updated
16 min: Dupont throws a dummy to his left and then makes one of those lightning little breaks, on the left, and produces a lovely one-handed offload to Paul Willemse on his inside, offering the ball up softly despite the fact he’s travelling at some pace. Marchand then takes it up, and is absolutely smashed by a brilliant tackle from an Italian defender, although I didn’t see who it was. France take it through more phases, and they are in again!
Updated
15 min: Ntamack kicks a penalty from distance but he misses it, narrowly, to the left.
14 min: Italy get the line-out right, which is good, but then Julien Marchand is allowed to steal the ball out of a ruck for France, which is not good. Dupont is freed down the left but it breaks down for the hosts.
It’s the same old story for Italy, they are totally incapable of building any continuity, so far.
Updated
12 min: Fickou takes the ball into contact for France on the left wing now, and concedes a penalty for holding on. Good defensive work from Italy. Can they mount some kind of platform?
“It will be interesting to see how their line-out functions without Zanni,” says O’Connell on co-commentary.
10 min: France are on the front foot again. Ntamack tries another little grubber kick into the danger area, on the same side of the pitch, but Italy mop this one up well, seeing the danger nice and early. Allan with the clearing kick, but France have a good attacking line-out now.
Updated
Try! 7 min: France 8-0 Italy (Teddy Thomas)
A lovely little grubber by France fly-half Ntamack on the right-hand side of the pitch, as France look at it, and it’s the first try. Thomas charges on to the bouncing ball, which kicks up above head height in the in-goal area. He grabs it and touches down. Ntamack misses the conversion attempt. A super start by France, and an ominous one from an Italian point of view ...
Updated
4 min: Full-back Hayward tries a dart from deep for Italy, but is double-tackled emphatically in midfield. Italy keep possession well, though, until Tommaso Allan is smashed by France’s rush defence.
Updated
3 min: Penalty! France 3-0 Italy (Romain Ntamack)
Straight through the middle.
Updated
2 min: Early possession and pressure for France. A cute offload by the prop Cyril Baille helps to set up a number of phases. It ends when Anthony Bouthier knocks on, but it’s taken back by the referee for a penalty. A chance for France to get on the board.
Kick-off!
Italy get us started. France are playing in white jerseys with blue shorts and white socks ... Italy are all in blue.
Updated
Here we go then ... two belting national anthems ring around the stadium, and we are a couple of minutes from kick-off.
My weather forecasting skills need work. I wrote earlier that Storm Ciara would not arrive in Paris until after the match, but it’s just started raining. Hopefully it won’t affect the spectacle too much ...
Updated
A bit of late team news: Second row Dean Budd comes into the Italy XV after Alessandro Zanni was injured in the warm-up:
❗ #Italrugby, un cambio nel XV titolare per #FRAvITA: @deanbuddd sostituirà Alessandro #Zanni, infortunatosi durante il riscaldamento@SixNationsRugby #insieme #rugbypassioneitaliana
— Italrugby (@Federugby) February 9, 2020
‘Durante il riscaldamento’ translates as ‘during heating’ on Twitter, but let’s stick with the warm-up.
Updated
Worsley analyses Italy’s chances: “If Italy try to run through the first four, five defenders near rucks, they are going to have a long day. They need to move the ball and find the space. They need to get around that wall of defenders that crushed the England attack last week.”
Interestingly, Italy carried the ball for more metres than any other team in Round 1. Considering they failed to score a point and conceded 42 that is quite a surprise.
But that was very much the story of their performance: they showed attacking intent when they had the ball, and actually caused Wales a problem here and there, but without the ball they were all over the shop.
Raphaël Ibañez talks to the BBC: “We will do our best ... we need to play some smart rugby, we need to play with the conditions [high winds]. We need to deal with it.
Asked how to stop the younger players getting carried away with the hype after the win against England: “It’s pretty simple, by training harder. This week, preparation went well. We take nothing for granted. The England game was excellent, the team spirit was good, but it’s gone. It’s about Italy ... it’s a new challenge to see if the boys can perform against Italy with a shorter turnaround.”
Updated
Paul O’Connell reminisces about facing a Franco Smith-coached team, Treviso, for his province Munster: “We beat them regularly, but they were very innovative.”
Damning with faint praise?
Updated
Italy coach Franco Smith speaks to the BBC: “Nothing’s going to happen overnight ... but we’re going to compete as well as we can against a very good French side.
“Wales were very, very good last week ... but we had our opportunities and we created a lot more than we thought. It’s about establishing our DNA and we’ve got another chance today.”
It’s opening montage time on the BBC, with a few highlights of the French success against England last week.
Luke McLean, Joe Worsley, Thomas Castaignède and Paul O’Connell form a four-man pundit panel alongside presenter Gabby Logan.
“Shaun Edwards can create a very ‘dangerous’ defence for France, that will create opportunities for their attack,” says Worsley.
It looks pretty windy in the stadium in Paris, although nowhere near as bad as it was up in Scotland yesterday.
Updated
Ireland produced an excellent display in beating Wales in Dublin yesterday. It would seem the work of Mike Catt, their new attack coach, is paying dividends already.
Looking ahead a couple of weeks, head coach Andy Farrell will take his team to Twickenham, where of course his son Owen will be waiting with England. Here is Michael Aylwin:
Yesterday, France’s women bounced back from last week’s defeat by England with a 45-10 thrashing of Italy. That’s the same Italy that won away in Wales last week. It’s a funny old game, and no mistake.
🇫🇷🇮🇹 AFFAMÉES !
— France Rugby (@FranceRugby) February 8, 2020
Les Bleues se sont battues pendant plus de 80mn pour offrir un magnifique spectacle devant un Stade Beaublanc comblé !
Bravo et merci les Bleues 🙏#FRAITA #XVdeFrance #NeFaisonsXV pic.twitter.com/aOxlMFdgss
England coach Eddie Jones was left distinctly unimpressed by the behaviour of some of Scotland’s supporters yesterday. Here is Gerard Meagher with the story:
Today’s Scotland v England women’s Six Nations match fell foul of the weather, unfortunately ... Manchester City v West Ham went the same way, along with some WSL fixtures, some horse racing ... the list goes on:
Inside the Azzurri’s changing room in the bowels of Stade de France. Not much going on, to be honest.
🔵 #Italrugby
— Italrugby (@Federugby) February 9, 2020
Lo spogliatoio degli Azzurri 💙
La squadra sta per arrivare allo Stade de France 💪@SixNationsRugby #FRAvITA#insieme #rugbypassioneitaliana pic.twitter.com/vY3xNIbTVa
Do you think Italy can put up a decent fight today? Do feel free to get in touch on email or Twitter with any thoughts on the match.
Submissions on yesterday’s Six Nations matches will also be accepted. Anything to do with rugby is fine. Anything not to do with rugby is fine too. Basically, please send me an email.
Updated
LA COMPO DES BLEUS!
🇫🇷🇮🇹 LA COMPO DES BLEUS !
— France Rugby (@FranceRugby) February 7, 2020
💥 Voici les 23 joueurs qui affronteront l'Italie dimanche !
Venez les encourager il reste des places !
🎟️ https://t.co/cF2pMlkZNY#NeFaisonsXV #XVdeFrance #FRAITA pic.twitter.com/XAGKqu0cjM
Of the one change to his starting line-up - Arthur Vincent coming in at outside-centre - Galthié had this to say:
“Vincent is a player who has the perfect career course. We expect him to be himself, with his strengths, his maturity but also his youth. He is a multi-purpose centre, first or second, capable of being a regulator or an accelerator.”
Sounds useful. Will the French back division have as much joy as Wales did last week? If so, we will be in for a feast of attacking rugby.
Teams
The injured Virimi Vakatawa is replaced by Arthur Vincent in one change for the hosts. Vincent, a former France Under-20 captain, will play at outside-centre.
France: Anthony Bouthier, Teddy Thomas, Arthur Vincent, Gaël Fickou, Vincent Rattez, Romain Ntamack, Antoine Dupont, Cyril Baille, Julien Marchand, Mohamed Haouas, Bernard Le Roux, Paul Willemse, François Cros, Charles Ollivon (capt), Grégory Alldritt.
Replacements: Peato Mauvaka, Jefferson Poirot, Demba Bamba, Romain Taofifenua, Boris Palu, Cameron Woki, Baptiste Serin, Matthieu Jalibert.
Italy coach Franco Smith has reacted to that drubbing in Cardiff by making one change: Jayden Hayward is in at full-back, meaning Matteo Minozzi goes to the wing, while Leonardo Sarto is left out of the matchday squad.
Italy: Jayden Hayward, Mattia Bellini, Luca Morisi, Carlo Canna, Matteo Minozzi, Tommaso Allan, Callum Braley, Andrea Lovotti, Luca Bigi (c), Giosuè Zilocchi, Alessandro Zanni, Niccolò Cannone, Sebastian Negri, Jake Polledri, Abraham Steyn.
Replacements: Federico Zani, Danilo Fischetti, Marco Riccioni, Dean Budd, Federico Ruzza, Giovanni Licata, Guglielmo Palazzani, Giulio Bisegni.
Preamble
According to Ellis Genge, the ‘sausages’ set their sights on England in the wake of last weekend’s defeat in Paris.
France themselves will surely face a cassoulet of criticism should they somehow lose to Italy at Stade de France today, so soon after that stirring starter against Les Rosbifs.
Don’t bet on it. It’s early days, but things are looking up for Les Bleus under their new coach Fabien Galthié, particularly with a portion of English beef added to the backroom staff in the shape of defence coach Shaun Edwards.
As Eddie Jones’s men were reminded, France have always known how to attack. Scrum-half Antoine Dupont, in particular, terrorised the opposition seven days ago. Should France add defensive discipline to their potent attacking arsenal, with the help of Edwards, they are going to be almost impossible to stop in this tournament.
The Azzurri, also under new management with Franco Smith, were battered 42-0 by Wales last week. It was over before it really began, and although their defence left much to be desired, they didn’t acquit themselves quite as badly as the scoreline suggests. They possess some dangerous runners but there is rarely any structure or continuity to their attack. Building periods of pressure through sustained phase play should be their target.
While Sunday’s sporting events in the UK are dropping like flies due to the extreme weather, Storm Ciara seems set to leave Paris untouched, at least until after the concluding match of the second round of the 2020 Six Nations.
The formbook says Italy will be reduced to thinly-sliced salami. France will want nothing less than a bonus-point win. Let’s hope for a sliver of success for Italy, at the very least. Teams to follow.