8th over: England 73-0 (Banton 44, Duckett 24) Duckett steps to the crease to face just his 10th delivery of the innings as Bartlett changes ends. The opener punches a straight drive just out of reach of the bowler’s left hand to immediately pick up a couple. Duckett gets up on his toes to punish a wider ball with a cut to the rope, then clobbers a drive past a diving Connolly and smacks the same shot again to make it three boundaries in as many balls. Another 15 runs added to England’s total as alarm bells are ringing for Australia.
7th over: England 58-0 (Banton 44, Duckett 9) Mahli Beardman is called into the attack with Australia desperate for a wicket. The 21-year-old took six of them in his ODI debut in Perth but Banton welcomes him to Hobart with a scorching boundary through a gap at mid-off. Beardman responds as he beats the bat with the ball napping back in off the seam. But Banton crunches another boundary with a drive down the ground to take another 10 from the over.
6th over: England 48-0 (Banton 34, Duckett 9) England are taking this game away from Australia as Banton clobbers Johnson for four boundaries in the over. The first might have been the best of the lot with an exquisite drive off the half-volley, then adds a second through mid-off. A shorter ball is pulled to the rope at deep square leg then Banton unloads with another, better timed, pull to the same area. An ominous 17 from the over.
5th over: England 31-0 (Banton 17, Duckett 9) Bartlett has looked the better of the two Australia quicks but Banton doesn’t need much to go wrong to find a boundary. A straighter ball is slightly overpitched and the England opener hammers a drive back past Bartlett before he can get his hands anywhere near it. Banton finds back-to-back boundaries as he whips an inswinger off his hip but is fortunate to watch a leading edge fly in the air through a vacant backward point.
4th over: England 22-0 (Banton 8, Duckett 9) Johnson yet to get the ball moving too much in the air. Duckett punishes an overpitched delivery with a sublime straight drive through Johnson’s hands and to the rope. The Australia quick has the ball drifting behind the left-handed Duckett for a wide either side of the boundary. Duckett opens up again as Johnson drops short with a pull through the gap at midwicket. Johnson will hope to have an opportunity to make amends, but that was all too loose.
3rd over: England 12-0 (Banton 8, Duckett 1) Bartlett gives Banton a bit more width and the England opener slashes in the air and barely over point. He’ll gladly accept the four runs but Bartlett won’t mind that sort of stroke.
Updated
2nd over: England 8-0 (Banton 4, Duckett 1) Spencer Johnson takes the new ball and Banton glances for a couple that are called leg byes. Banton chips a fuller ball off his toes for two behind square. Australia rise as one with a shout for lbw as Johnson, coming around the wicket, gets the ball to nip back into Banton. Just a few issues with that one as the ball pitched outside leg stump, struck the pad outside the line and kept drifting further away. Don’t ask, don’t get.
1st over: England 3-0 (Banton 2, Duckett 1) Bartlett immediately has the ball shaping away from the right-hander Banton. The opener is coming off a match-defining knock of 121 from 99 balls in Adelaide, and starts with a pair of singles today in Hobart. Duckett picks up a single with a glance to fine leg.
Xavier Bartlett has the white pill in his hand and is at the top of his mark as the sun belts down at Bellerive Oval. Tom Banton marks centre with Ben Duckett at the non-striker’s end. Let’s play …
We’re about five minutes away from what some of us are here for – the third ODI between Australia and England. Begin to shift your minds away from the ongoing sandpaper saga by learning more about how, ahem, cheaters still might prosper, as the Secret Cricket Coach tells us a tale …
I once played in a one-day semi-final. We were in a very tight spot when I edged the ball to the keeper. I didn’t walk. The opposition couldn’t believe it. They crowded around me, furious, and I was getting plenty of abuse.
I managed to get a single and when I reached the other end the umpire said: ‘You didn’t nick that did you? You are a walker.’ ‘Yep, that’s right,’ I replied.
David Warner is seated next to Khawaja and ready to have his say as he starts by making the point that he does not want to see further sanctions imposed …
Look, we put our hands up. We accept what Cricket Australia handed down to us. It’s not about penalties. It’s just about coming out with transparency and accountability in which, Todd’s acknowledged on CA’s behalf about the culture at the time with the players and CA .So I respect that again. And I think everyone just wants to see cricket played on our TV.
Yes, people want to talk about moving on. But in this safe environment, we want every single person that’s there to be able to speak. We all want to move on. There’s no clearer thing from everyone than we want to move on. The question is, will this allow us to move on? That’s the question that has to be asked.
Updated
But for me, there’s still a few questions to be had. … I respect Todd Greenberg and David Boon, what they just said there. I respect that Todd Greenberg has acknowledged that CA and the culture and the team had all played a role in this. I respect that. This safe space again, is it really going to be safe? … are we going to get down to what the public want? Is the truth? Where do we actually end here? Because it is upon the board to review what they want to be published.
Yes, that’s a safe space, but is everyone going to be able to talk? When you say that, what do you mean everyone? Why won’t they be able to talk? Well, I would have liked a open, independent inquiry. And the people that were there at the time actually can come forward and speak. Because we have no idea about what’s happened behind closed doors with CA and the previous employees at Cricket Australia. …
But I think at the end of the day, if you’re going to cherry pick what is said in this investigation, in this report, how they can choose, the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out.Are we just going in a circle here? That’s the thing that I’m not sure about.
Khawaja continues …
And I agree, I don’t think there should be any sanctions. I don’t think the price is being paid. It was a hefty price. It’s never been about that. But the biggest question I have, and I wrote it down, is the board makes the decisions of what comes out at the end. How is that an actual way of trying to present what people have said? So I could go in there and say something, but then the board can decide that they’re not going to release that. And I just feel like then we just go in a circle again of, this is happening, that’s happening, you’re not going to talk about it. I appreciate where their heart is. And I’ll support the board in this. I’ve never been one, I just wanted to take accountability, and I’ve done it for the three guys who I think were unfairly treated.
Usman Khawaja is on Kayo Cricket at just the right time to respond immediately to CA CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boon announcing how they hope to move the game forward in Australia.
Personally, from my point of view, I’ve always wanted a safe space to chat. I wish Cricket Australia would have done this a week and a half ago, probably longer ago. The fact remains that I had the same conversation with my wife. There needs to be a safe space where we can chat.
But I also have some questions about Cricket Australia because the public want to know what happened there. It’s hard to get the whole truth unless everyone is speaking, support staff and players. And so if you leave that open-ended, what are you finding? My questions will always be, what is the outcome from this?
Mitch Marsh confirms that Adam Zampa is a late out, along with Riley Meredith, while Alex Carey has been added to the side now sporting a pair of keepers with Josh Inglis also named for the third ODI in Hobart.
England XI
England: Ben Duckett, Tom Banton, Joe Root, Harry Brook (capt), Jordan Cox (wk), Will Jacks, Sam Curran, Liam Dawson, Sonny Baker, Gus Atkinson, Jofra Archer.
Harry Brook sticks to a winning formula with the same XI that blasted their way to a 135-run victory in Adelaide.
Australia XI
Australia: Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh (capt), Cooper Connolly, Josh Inglis (wk), Matt Renshaw, Cameron Green, Alex Carey, Jack Edwards, Xavier Bartlett, Spencer Johnson, Mahli Beardman.
In a nod to the future Australia have recalled young pace bowler Beardman who took six wickets in his ODI debut in Perth before being rested for the second match in Adelaide.
Usman Khawaja and David Warner are responding on Kayo Cricket to CA’s plans to offer a forum for players and the rest of the touring party to share their story from the 2018 Test series in South Africa. More on that shortly …
England win the toss and elect to bat
While sandpapergate rears its ugly head again, Australia captain Mitch Marsh and England skipper Harry Brook have been on Bellerive Oval for the toss. Brook has called correctly and elected to bat first.
Cricket Australia will open a forum for players and staff on the tour of South Africa in 2018 to share their stories. But there will be no new investigation or sanctions imposed for there. There is no confirmation that the findings or comments will be made public.
“This forum is not about re-litigating the past,” CA’s interim chair David Boon said. “It’s about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment – and for our sport to listen.”
Our concern is the future the game and to make sure that we can move forward strongly, unified and in the traditions that this game has made for us all.
To finish off, I’m a great believer in what Sir Donald Bradman said and you have all heard it before; We don’t own the game. We’re to be involved in it and leave our legacy, what we leave behind is to make it better for others. That’s what we’re to do.
David Boon is speaking again and is asked why CA will not confirm that you will make what they learned from this forum public.
As Todd has said … we’ll take recommendations to the board from whoever is to conduct this independent review and forum and the opinions, but there’s going to be different versions, and as we’ve said they will be debated and put to the board, and we will make a decision then.
I think everyone to take some level of accountability and CA is part of that. We’ve said a number of times through different players that the culture at that time was quite toxic. It was a difficult dressing room, it was a win at all costs mentality. And that doesn’t just start with a group of players. It comes an entire organisation. And I think there’s a a level of responsibility we have to accept.
In saying that, I think the game the Australian cricket team has learned enormous lessons from that time. And credit goes to first of all Justin Langer and Tim Paine, who who recreated the culture that team over the first four years. And to Andrew McDonald and Pat Cummins who’ve picked that up and taken to another level.
There’s plenty of players talking me about this issue and their hope is to have this issue wrapped so we can start talking about cricket. And hopefully this will help do that.
Greenberg is asked if this is the “best way to clear the captain”?
The captain doesn’t need to be cleared. No one’s to be cleared. The investigation was complete. What we’re to do is give people an opportunity to complete their version of events. We’ve got almost everyone’s version of events and they differ markedly. That is the greatest challenge with this project is people’s version of events the time differ substantially. And we have to give enormous respect for each individual. Whether that’s different to someone else’s that’s understandable. But is a reality.
Greenberg is asked whether CA will be back here when David Warner releases his own book.
We can only do what we think is best. We’re trying to make the best decisions we can on behalf of cricket. The CA board met last night late into the night talking through this. We think this is the next natural step. It creates a place for players to be. I think that’s really important because what’s come clearly is that some players weren’t given that opportunity at that time. That’s not being critical of that investigation. It’s just it was a moment in time. And so they weren’t provided that opportunity, that opportunity now exists. And they’re not compelled to do it. We’re not forcing anyone to say or do anything. If they would like to do it, in a space without judgment, without sanction this is now being open for them.
Updated
This is not about appeasing any individual. It is about the sport. The game needs to move on somehow from these events eight years ago. They caused enormous pain and for lots of people they’re hurting again. Now at some point we have to move forward and we can’t move forward without putting some of these steps in place.
I think it’s pretty clear over the last weeks, I think the game has suffered enormously. As I said before I think the game’s really hurting at the moment. And there are relationships and friendships from players that have shared dressing rooms for that are under enormous strain. It’s incumbent on us to find a path forward.
The game is bigger than all of us. We all love cricket. We’re here get more kids and more people watching and we’ve got to find a way to get past this and it’s been very difficult to do so.
I’ve spent a lot of time reading through the investigation. Eight of the 11 players who played that Test match were interviewed. A number of staff were interviewed. People can be critical of what happened there.
Cameron [Bancroft] is entitled, just like every other player to share their views. He can use this mechanism to share his views. He can share them publicly. And every other player should be afforded exactly the same right.
Greenberg says the terms of the forum are being “drafted as we speak” with it still to be determined who will have oversight of the process.
It will likely be a KC, a former judge someone of that ilk. It’ll be completely independent to Cricket Australia and will sit outside of Cricket Australia.
I think we will move as quickly as we can, but we don’t want to rush this. Clearly we want to give time and space for players and staff to come forward. They need to consider in their own way and we want to allow them to take the time that it needs. I’m hoping we can wrap up it quickly though.
Updated
I do know the versions of events conflict with each other and people’s view of their events conflict with each other, that is probably the most complex part of this. I would say this though, anyone who comes in to this forum to provide their story, I would encourage them to be as specific as possible. It’s hard to deal with generalities. And so I am hopeful creating a safe space for players to their version of events is an important moment.
The forum is designed where people who weren’t interviewed or weren’t offered the opportunity or didn’t feel they had the opportunity to contribute to now contribute. We want to be able to give the opportunity that they deserve.
We are indeed very, very proud the culture that this team has built the past eight years. Our players our leaders, our coaches deserve enormous credit for that. In particular Pat and Andrew who continue to lead this team with distinction. But we recognise the pain and the hurt that events surrounding sandpaper have caused. The game is genuinely hurting the moment. It’s not good for anyone. We need to find a path through, we need some time to heal.
As of this process, and so all parties who wish to can tell their version of events we have set up now an independent forum, a chance to give everyone a voice in an independent a safe setting. It’s not investigation. It’s not to produce a sanction. No one is forced to participate. It is entirely up to each individual. It’s important to remember we’re talking about events that happened eight a half years ago. And I hope everyone will respect this process the players be afforded the space to at their best at what is a very important time and period for the game.
CA CEO Todd Greenberg is ready to speak …
For the past week we’ve had several different and conflicting accounts of what occurred in Cape Town in 2018. And it’s an incredibly difficult and uncomfortable time the game and for who was involved. What happened then and continues to play out has a to do with the culture that existed back at the time, a culture that CA played a part in creating.
Australian cricket is at its strongest when we’re united and we owe it to those who love the game to make every reasonable effort to move forward together with understanding respect and perspective. As a former player, I know that one of the most important things cricket gives us is relationships and friendships we build that endure long after we’ve finished playing. My hope is that this process can help strengthen those connections and allow to focus on what lies ahead.
For a decade the fallout from these events, or from those, has remained part of conversation around Australian cricket It’s been a difficult chapter for many people and increasingly the ongoing debate has become a distraction for our game. We believe it is time a circuit breaker. This forum is not about reliving the past at all. It’s about creating an opportunity for those who wish be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment and for our sport to listen.
Updated
CA interim chair David Boon is first to speak …
I just want to really speak directly to all Australian cricket fans. Last night the Cricket Australia board met and we reached a decision that we believe is in the best interests of the game. After careful discussion, we agreed to establish a forum that will allow players and staff involved the events of South Africa in 2018 to share their experiences and their perspectives.
Updated
Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boon are ready to speak to the media at Bellerive Oval in Hobart. The former Australia batter will be up first. Follow what they have to say here …
Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boon will be ready to speak at about 1.30pm AEDT. Not hard to guess the reason for them stepping up to the mic ahead of the third ODI between Australia and England, after Usman Khawaja reignited the debate around sandpapergate with his book and comments made on the promotional tour.
Khawaja has since insisted he has tried to balance standing up for David Warner, Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft with the cost to other players with his bombshell ball-tampering claims.
“I have stood up for three guys I feel like were treated unfairly,” Khawaja told Antoinette Lattouf on the They Used to Be podcast. “But there are other guys that are still playing in the team right now that there might be some sort of cost. I have tried my best to balance that out.
“There is always a cost in everything you do. There has been a cost to my family too. But I am also not playing the victim here, because I knew what I was getting into. I knew what was coming. I just didn’t realise it would be so personal.”
Updated
Ian Healy is a voice worth listening to after spending more than a decade in the Australia Test team. Find out what Australia’s touring party to South Africa in 2018 has said about sandpapergate over the years and during the most recent debate.
Australia Test great Ian Healy has said cricketers on the sandpaper tour of South Africa in 2018 will be remembered as “liars forever” while questioning why Usman Khawaja reignited the debate with the release of his book eight years on from the ball tampering scandal in Cape Town.
Hopefully we got close to the truth in the investigation; those who didn’t get an interview and didn’t go forward, they’re guilty whistleblowers now. They didn’t come forward when it was saveable, now there’s a massive stain on cricket and they’ll be known as liars forever.
Preamble
Hello and welcome to live coverage of the third one-day international – and ODI series decider – between Australia and England in Hobart. The series is all square at one win apiece after Australia opened their home summer with a rollicking seven-wicket win in Perth. But England turned the tables when plundering their highest ODI total in Australia to take out the second game by 135 runs in Adelaide. The strengths and weaknesses of both lineups have already been on show, while we’ll begin to find out in about an hour and a half which two sides have turned up at Bellerive Oval.
Cricket Australia will be as pleased as anyone if attention shifts to the 50-over contest between the arch-rivals today. But with the cloud of sandpapergate again hovering over the sport and the national team, the time has come for the governing body to have its say. CA interim chair David Boon and CEO Todd Greenberg will speak to the media at Bellerive Oval from 1.15pm – and we’ll follow along from here.
Mitch Marsh and Harry Brook will be out for the toss and to confirm their teams shortly after – with the first ball to be bowled at 2.30pm local/3.30am BST. In the meantime, get in touch with your thoughts and predictions by email or find me @martinpegan on Bluesky. Let’s get into it!