Not long ago a man I know was barred from a local charity shop. For haggling. He wasn’t trying to put a hole in their profits, he explained, rather it was in his blood to drive for a harder bargain whatever the circumstances. He couldn’t help it.
That was the attitude of the Springboks here a year ago when they had Ireland on toast and kept demanding more rounds. It’s in their blood too.
But here at a fully engaged Aviva Stadium, for their 12th Test of the season, they had to pay the full asking price demanded by an excellent Ireland.
The implications of this will be warmly greeted by a clutch of countries who are trying to get away from the prospect of South African power mowing down all-comers at next year’s World Cup. Wrapped up in that was the dominance we expect of them at the scrum, taking five penalties and two free kicks from that battle while giving up just one full penalty there to Ireland.
How they would have hoped that with the clock counting down and just three points separating them from Ireland, a scrum under the home posts was an Irish put-in. All day Ireland dialled up channel one on their scrum and got the answer they wanted. They did it again on this critical scrum, via Nick Timoney which was just as well for the replacement loosehead Tom O’Toole had been buried. Games are won and lost on moments like that.
It would have been cruel on Ireland had that gone differently for they played far more rugby, much of it a vastly different quality to what we’ve seen from them over summer and this autumn series which concludes in London next weekend with the finals.
“They’re (South Africa) not just the world champions but they’re the world No 1 as well and they’ve been playing outstanding rugby over the last 12 months,” Andy Farrell said. “So yeah, to come away with any kind of W we’ll take that. It was some effort by the lads. We kept turning up when we were trying to get back into the game after something disappointing, maybe scoring a try just after they did which shows the character of the lads.”
Ireland: Keenan, Baloucoune, Henshaw (Aki 28), McCloskey, Hansen; Prendergast, Gibson-Park; Porter (O'Toole 72), Kelleher (Stewart 61), Furlong (Clarkson 52), McCarthy (Ryan 61), Beirne, Baird, van der Flier (Timoney 61), Sheehan (Timoney 44).
Tries: Baloucoune 2, Kelleher. Con: Prendergast. Pen: Prendergast. Sin-bin: Sheehan 73.
South Africa: Willemse (Moodie 26); Arendse, Kriel, de Allende (Williams 64), Hooker; Feinberg-Mngomezelu, van den Berg; Nche (Steenekamp 48), Marx (Wessels 62), Louw (T du Toit 48), Etzebeth, Mostert (de Jager 48), Kolisi (de Villiers 48), P du Toit (Hanekom 53), Hanekom (van Staden 48).
Tries: van den Berg, Marx. Cons: Mngomezulu 2. Pen: Mngomezulu. Sin-bin: van Staden.
Referee: C Ridley (France).
They had a handful of outstanding performers – Rónan Kelleher along with Josh van der Flier and replacement Timoney were high on the list – and the man of the match award was wrapped in green before half-time. Robert Baloucoune is box office. Every time he gets his paws on the ball some piece of magic is about to unfold. Aside from aerial fetching he was involved in three try-scoring incidents: the first and third were good, the meat in the sandwich was lost under pressure from Damian Willemse and Cameron Hanekom.
In a gripping game we were invited to a game of chess where you could whack your opponent as you made your play. The aerial battle was full-on from the start with Hugo Keenan and Baloucoune keeping the casualty rate down for the home side.
The other game was the battle of wills: when offered penalties that had the potential for three points Ireland would drive past that exit and go to touch instead. Initially the Boks were more measured, with Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu taking three points from his first sight of the sticks.
Rassie Erasmus, who was serving the first of his six-match ban by staging a live stream of South Africa's match with Ireland, frequently turned off his microphone and covered his mouth to talk pointedly, at length, to someone. At other times he ducked down behind his laptop screen. He had an earpiece so could have be on the phone. The terms of his six-match World Rugby ban clearly stated he was not permitted “any match-day involvement including coaching, direct or indirect contact with team management or players on match days”. Luke McLaughlin
Then there was the scrum. South Africa’s calling card had been looked at up and down, inside and out, all week. A game of many scrums would surely sink Ireland? Sure enough the Boks took a free-kick and five penalties from that set-piece but there was enough left in the debate between the giant tighthead Wilco Louw and Andrew Porter to rule out foregone conclusions.
Ireland had their noses ahead at the break thanks to the quick response Farrell spoke about: Kelleher getting over in the corner just after Ireland had conceded to the excellent Morné van den Berg at the other end.
You could sense though that Farrell will also raise with his players the tries they left unfinished. Which is probably better than not creating the chance in the first place. The Boks too will review their three mistakes in the endgame which allowed Ireland hold out under what was intense pressure.