Dominic Fifield in Oporto 

Porto v Chelsea: Champions League webchat

Dominic Fifield was online from Portugal to answer your questions about José Mourinho’s return to Porto with Chelsea
  
  

How José Mourinho’s philosophy was formed

Thanks for reading and commenting. Dom is off to see a bit of Oporto. Here are those previews again. Enjoy the match...

PCQMark

Hi Dom. Last month, or not long ago, there have been speculations saying that if José was to leave Chelsea, he would still want to stay in the Premier League and manage one of the teams in London, and apparently, the one that’s rumoured to be was Arsenal. How true could you say, or is there any chance of him actually wanting to coach Arsenal rather than other London-based teams? Cheers.

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I'd imagine there would be absolutely no chance of that happening, to be perfectly honest!

theflyingscotsman2

Dom, what are your thoughts at the lack of investment in the Chelsea team during the summer? While Begovic is a good player, he is nowhere near Cech’s level, and the less said about Falcao the better after his performances for United last year. So far Chelsea have looked slow, unfit and unmotivated – do you think the lack of competition/new faces is the main catalyst for this?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Chelsea's biggest strength in the summer of 2014 was their effectiveness in the transfer market. They had Diego Costa and Filipe Luis lined up from Atletico Madrid very early on. They moved swiftly to secure Cesc Fabregas the moment they were aware he was available at Barcelona. Even when interest surfaced from Milan in Fernando Torres, they purchased a replacement of quality in Loic Remy very, very efficiently. And yet the contrast could not have been more stark in the summer of 2015. The additions they made were largely replacements: Begovic for Cech; Rahman for Luis; Falcao for Drogba. Kenedy was a kid who was going to be given time to develop. It was as if they realised very late on that more competition was needed, hence the urgent move to secure Pedro from Barca to add to their forward ranks. I know Mourinho has suggested publicly that he has been happy with the recruitment this season, but I'd imagine, privately, there was some real frustration there that more new faces were not brought in earlier in the summer to speed proper integration and adaptation, and simply ensure more competition for places.

RaghavJKBlues

As a Chelsea fan, I still believe in Jose. He is the right man for the job. We have to get rid of players like Terry, Ivanovic, Mikel, Remy and Falcao, who are too old to make it to present Premier League’s pace and physicality. Just give the youth a chance. There are fine players like RLC, Kenedy, Moses, Nathan, Bamford, Pasalic, Ake, Kalas, Solanke...

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Just glancing up to the screen here in the hotel and Chelsea's U19s are currently winning 3-1 against Porto in the Uefa youth league. There is so much talent there in the system, and they have 33 other players (most of them youngsters) out on loan. The difficult thing is to try and integrate those kids into the first-team at a club where every defeat is unexpected and almost unacceptable.

Paul Harris

Hi Dominic, do you actually think the constant complaining about external influences (bans etc) that Mourinho voices time and again is now becoming more of an excuse for this Chelsea team rather than a protective umbrella to deter criticism from his players and build the siege mentally he seems to enjoy?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I do think Mourinho is a master of deflecting issues, yes. And he uses that siege mentality time and time again to get the best from his squad, whichever club he is coaching at the time.

mynamewasneo

Hi Dominic, do you think Mourinho will ever win the CL with a proper big club, like Real Madrid?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I do think Mourinho is a master of deflecting issues, yes. And he uses that siege mentality time and time again to get the best from his squad, whichever club he is coaching at the time.

looselips

Hello Dominic. Fans in England have strong and largely negative opinions re Mourinho. What’s the view in Porto? Are Portuguese fans proud of their local boy made good, or conflicted by his calculated provocations and outbursts? (As a Chelsea fan, I’m deeply ambivalent about him.)

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I think he is still hugely appreciated in Porto (not as a local, given his connections with Setabul, but as a former Porto manager who enjoyed huge success here), though perhaps not as much as he is at Chelsea or even, maybe, with Inter. There is pride, though. What was achieved in 2003 and 2004 was phenomenal.

Friggity

Dominic, what’s your take on the form of Hazard? He seems reluctant to make the runs and dribbles he did over and over last season. It isn’t fatigue, he looked fit enough this weekend.

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I wonder whether he was one of the six players Mourinho dug out (without naming) this morning, suggesting it was down to "attitude". He clearly revived in the second half on Tyneside, but the frustration remains that he is only turning it on for periods in games. Mourinho spoke earlier this season about the responsibility now on Hazard to follow up on last year's success: as a reigning footballer of the year, he has set a standard he must now maintain. He has the lofty reputation now. But he still has to justify it every week.

Updated

DanteDanger:

Hi Dominic. What do you think Mourinho can do with his current squad to change things? He’s limited for options in defence with only really Baba Rahman coming in at left back to provide something different and he appears to be reluctant to bench Fabregas or Matic in the league. I appreciate tactics may not be the problem, but it looks to me that things need freshening up – maybe a 442 diamond:

Begovic
-Azpilicueta-Zouma-Cahill-Rahman
-----------------Matic--------------------
----------Ramires--Fabregas-----------
----------------Oscar----------------------
---------------Hazard---------------------
----------------Falcao--------------------

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

A diamond would be interesting, possibly with Hazard at its tip and Diego Costa (once the ban is served) partnered with either Falcao or Remy? Generally, Mourinho has stuck with his variations of 4-2-3-1 / 4-3-3 etc. I can't see him changing to much. He suggested yesterday that "tactics" aren't the problem. It is more down to "attitude".

MiguelAndrade:

Hi. Hope you enjoy the beautiful Porto. What team do you predict Mou will line-up tonight? Defensive midfield with Ramires and Matic or trusting Porto’s lack of central play and using a softer Fabregas, with Oscar, Hazard and Pedro behind Costa? Thanks

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

The team I went with in this morning's paper was...
Chelsea (4-2-3-1): Begovic; Ivanovic, Cahill, Terry, Azpilicueta; Ramires, Matic; Willian, Fabregas, Hazard; Diego Costa.
The city is fantastic, thanks. A beautiful place.

getdfunkout

Do you think José will start Terry today? If he does, who do you think will miss out: Zouma or Cahill? Also, is there any chance that he might start Ruben Loftus-Cheek or Kenedy tonight?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I'm inclined to think Terry will start at Zouma's expense, not least because the young Frenchman has made a few errors of his own of late (partly down to inexperience, I'd imagine). He is generally very good at recovering those mistakes - that is where his burst of pace is properly useful - but this may be an occasion to rely on some wiser old heads in Cahill and Terry.
I do wonder if there might be a surprise selection in there somewhere. You'd imagine Ramires and Willian are worth starts given the impact they made when coming off the bench on Saturday. But Kenedy might add a bit more forward thrust, and Loftus-Cheek has done well on the occasions he has started (albeit only against Tel Aviv and Walsall of late). He might be best utilised in a midfield three, possibly alongside Matic and Fabregas, though that would have implications for Oscar. We will see.

SpecialPG

The good thing about an opening day win, is that a draw is a great result away to your biggest rivals in the group - even a defeat is not a disaster.

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

And Chelsea don't have a particularly staggering away record in European competition in recent years. Can see this ending in a draw tonight, which would constitute a pretty good result. Actually, a very good one.

Matthias Mueller

Is Mourinho in danger of ‘losing the locker room’? Do you really not think physical exhaustion has a role to play in this for some of the key players?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Exhaustion, definitely, has played a part. Chelsea had one of the smaller "senior" squads last season (albeit they loan so many of their fringe and young players out - 33 this year alone) which placed even more onus on key figures featuring every week. The fact they began the campaign so well also meant Mourinho was reluctant to "change a winning formula" etc until it all became a bit of a slog over the run-in. I suspect we are still witnessing the hangover from that now: Terry played every in the Premier League last season; Ivanovic featured in every game. That has taken its toll. But I don't think Mourinho is in danger of losing the dressing-room. Not at present, anyway. The comments yesterday, while inflammatory, were tactical and aimed at coaxing more from his players. Cesc Fabregas in many way reiterated those sentiments when he faced the media last night.

SamtheShameless

How many red cards will Costa get this season?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

He hasn't been shown a red card since 2010. Though I do think that, given he has now twice been sanctioned retrospectively, there will inevitably be even more scrutiny on his every move once he returns from this latest three-match absence. Tonight should be interesting. You'd imagine he'd be raring to tear into Porto given he's had to sit out the last two games. Could be explosive...

sharri19

Dominic, is there any concern among the Chelsea hierarchy about how the club is perceived outside of its support? Recent events – namely the behaviour of the manager, star striker and the ostracising of the club’s doctor - have obviously been frowned upon by the wider world of football. Do Chelsea care?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I think they do care, quite a bit. Massively, in fact.

SmileyFZ

Ivanovic has been consistently awful this season and has been involved in, even if not solely responsible, for the majority of the many goals conceded. José has not problem dropping Terry- yet he refuses to even acknowledge Ivanovic’s form – even making him Captain with when Terry is not playing. At times it has felt like Jose has sabotaged the team by playing him – why do you think this is and why do the media not question José more about this?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Good question. I guess Terry is in a more exposed position in the centre, particularly against raw pace, and Chelsea have other options in the middle with Zouma and Cahill. Their options at right-back are slightly more limited, even if Cesar Azpilicueta is a natural on that side. The problem is, playing the Spaniard there would mean using Baba Rahman from the current squad at left-back and, while there has been promise in his performances so far, he still looks as if he has a mistake or two defensively in him while he adjusts to a new league etc.
All that said, I agree that Ivanovic has been uncharacteristically error-prone this season. Actually, it might go back as far as the Spring when a long season appeared to take its toll on him and wingers started having a bit more joy on his side of the pitch. I thought he was snapping out of it when he looked a bit more impressive - and aggressive - against (a very poor) Maccabi Tel Aviv and Arsenal, but Newcastle seemed to exploit him on Saturday again.
Mourinho suggested up to six players were not performing up to scratch on Saturday, and I'd imagine Ivanovic was probably one of them. The manager considers him a leader, someone who should inspire the younger players in the set-up, but his form has been dismal to date. Terry, I'd imagine, would return this evening. I was surprised he wasn't selected up against Mitrovic on Saturday, but it would constitute more of a shock if he didn't start tonight in what is Chelsea's most daunting fixture in Group G.

ManUFanBaby

Do you think Chelsea can win the tournament? If I recall correctly, they finished outside the top four the last time they won it.

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

To be honest, I can't really see any of the English clubs winning the trophy this season. Can you? Given how well the first round of matches went, the priority for all four should be to qualify from the groups and then see what happens. Mourinho himself was rather sceptical of his team's chances last night: "We're favourites for the group but, in the last 16, we'll see what happens." I suspect events against Paris Saint-Germain last year troubled him significantly. I think I suggested Bayern Munich might win it when we did our pre-tournament predictions, which means Pep Guardiola and his side have absolutely no chance. Clearly.

Diego D’Amour

Saint Iker will, tonight, become the player with most appearances in the Champions League. Dare we hope for a clean sheet and another metaphorical, reciprocal poke in the eye for the increasingly tetchy and ‘found out as not so special after all’ Mourinho?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Mourinho gave that issue very short shrift last night at his press conference. The first journalist who asked a question and identified himself as from Spain was cut short with the Chelsea manager saying: "If you're going to ask me about Casillas, I'm going to greet him at the beginning and the end. No more questions about it.” And that was it. The local national broadcaster's coverage of tonight's game has already included a lengthy feature on the whole issue. Yet another "handshake watch" awaits, I fear.

cianmulligan

Hi Dominic. Do you think tonight is the night that Radamel Falcao is finally cured of his Champions League phobia? What are your thoughts on why Falcao has curiously shunned club football’s elite competition for so long? I am not a conspiracy theorist, but his record looks extremely curious for a top-level striker – his first year or two at Porto aside, it seems he has a habit of helping clubs reach the Champions League, then moving on immediately. Is something dodgy afoot?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Interesting point, that. Casting an eye over Uefa's statistics, he has played eight games in the Champions League and scored four goals, which is surprisingly few for a player who was considered, prior to the knee injury, as one of the best forwards on the planet. I guess it has been about when opportunities arose for him: he has quite an active agent in Jorge Mendes, after all. To move from Atletico Madrid to AS Monaco constituted a surprise, although at that stage Dmitry Rybolovlev was spending millions to kick-start his club's challenge having taken them out of Ligue 2. Bottom line, unfortunately, is that the knee injury has wrecked the player's progress. I'm not sure we'll ever see him at his rampaging best again (watching him tear Chelsea to pieces in the 2012 SuperCup was something else), which is cruel. Jose Mourinho clearly thought he could restore him to the pinnacle but, given how he has been used to date, I wonder whether reality is sinking in once again...

mindmetoes:

Do you think Chelsea’s low balling of Everton and public campaign to try and destabilise John Stones has come back to bite Mourinho on the arse?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

The failure to sign Stones, who Chelsea clearly thought they could secure, did set them back significantly in their summer strengthening. Everton's resistance, though, was admirable and completely justified: Premier League clubs boast that clout these days with the revenues they are generating through broadcast rights etc. They have their own ambitions and targets. And now Stones' development will continue with regular involvement at centre-half at Everton for the foreseeable future.
I imagine, at some stage, Chelsea will revisit the issue and try to prise him away again but Everton have made clear they will only countenance his departure when it suits them. And quite right too.

CountAwesome

Hi Dominic, is this the worst situation Mourinho has been in as a top-flight manager? I know we’re only two months into the season, but is he feeling any serious pressure?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I do think it's a new experience for him, yes. He hasn't endured anything like this at any of his "elite" clubs, and there is an awareness that he cannot be seen simply to allow the situation to drift. Carlo Ancelotti, during the prolonged "difficult moment" he suffered from November 2010, could offer no real explanation for why things were unravelling, which simply suggested he was a manager unable to arrest the decline. Mourinho will be keen to illustrate he is not in the same position: he is being proactive, trying to eke out more from his players in any way he can. That manifested itself yesterday in some pretty strong criticisms, and a warning that he will simply "go with the kids" if it gets to the point where Chelsea are out of the running for major honours this season.

theflyingscotsman2

Dom, while there is no doubt that Mou will go down in footballing history as one of the most successful managers of all time. But do you really think he has what it takes to build a lasting legacy at a club, a la Ferguson or Wenger? Also, could you ever see a Porto-return for the special/happy/moany one?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

I would be surprised to see Mourinho return to Porto, to be honest. He has suggested in the past his career may take him into international management - he has spoken of coaching Portugal on numerous occasions - when he does, eventually, leave Chelsea for a second time. Talking to local journalists at the Dragao last night, the suggestion was that, while Mourinho is still hugely respected here for what he achieved with the Uefa Cup in 2003 and the European Cup a year later, Andre Villas-Boas is almost revered more in these parts. AVB was a Porto supporter, I suppose, while Mourinho is from Setubal, but that still surprised me a bit...
As for a legacy, that is his great task at Chelsea this time around. He would argue it was "his team" which went on to claim the Premier League under Carlo Ancelotti, and even the European Cup under Roberto di Matteo. The core of those sides had been shaped (if not necessarily all bought) during his successful first spell at Stamford Bridge. In his eyes, therefore, he did leave a legacy last time around. But this is a different type of side, a different type of "project", and he recognises it as a very new kind of challenge for him. Something he's not done before.
Indeed, in a press conference the other day, he was asked about why things tend to go awry in his third seasons at clubs (when, indeed, he enjoys a third season). His initial response was rather angry and dismissive before the question was rephrased to "how important, then, is it to build a dynasty at a club beyond three or four seasons?"
His response: "I haven't done that. This is the first time I'm going for that, and I don't have experience of it in the past.” i.e. this is very much uncharted territory, which actually makes the day-to-day development of this team (whether progress or set-backs) all the more interesting.

Nickthemightyred

Isn’t this just a lot of hot air, much in line with Mourinho’s persona?

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

This webchat, you mean? Or Mourinho's pre-match comments questioning his players' "motivation, desire and commitment"? I think the latter reflected his deep-lying frustrations at the way in which his team have performed to date this season. He is seeking a response, as Cesc Fabregas also suggested last night at his own media conference, starting this evening at the Dragao. Too much of this team's season has been inconsistent to date: lethargy in long periods of games; a lack of urgency and invention going forward; defensive frailties. All very un-Chelsea-like, under Mourinho at least.

User avatar for domfifield Guardian staff

Hello all from Oporto. Jose Mourinho confronts his former club here tonight. He was pottering around the (very impressive) Porto museum at the Dragao last night ahead of his pre-match press conference looking fairly relaxed for someone who is clearly dissatisfied with the way his team is currently performing. Tonight should be a real test. Right...

Updated

Dominic will be online from 1pm BST

In the meantime, here are some of our previews:

And here are this week’s fixtures:

Barcelona v Bayer Leverkusen
BATE v Roma
Arsenal v Olympiakos
Bayern Munich v Dinamo Zagreb
Porto v Chelsea
Maccabi Tel Aviv v Dynamo Kiev
Lyon v Valencia
Zenit v Gent
Malmo v Real Madrid
Shaktar v PSG
CSKA v PSV
Manchester United v Wolfsburg
Astana v Galatasaray

Enjoy the webchat

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*