Here’s Robert Kitson’s match report of England’s bonus-point victory in Rome:
“At least Eddie Jones’s side could await the outcome of the championship’s last tango in Paris knowing they could have done no more.”
Will it be enough? We will know in a few hours’ time. Thank you for reading today, have a good evening, and I sincerely hope you get the result you are hoping for later tonight! Bye.
Updated
My colleague Lee Calvert is going to bring you all the action from Paris this evening.
And he has pointed out, importantly, that if Ireland beat France by six points, they will win the championship on tries scored, presuming they score at least one try tonight. Will we see a nerve-jangling finale? Keep up with all the action here:
A sentiment we can all get behind ... let’s hope France v Ireland is a rip-roaring affair, in contrast to that mostly stodgy stuff we just saw from Rome:
Whoever wins I just hope France v Ireland is a good spectacle. Not a particularly Super Saturday so far...
— robert kitson (@robkitson) October 31, 2020
Updated
Ben Youngs snaffled the man of the match vote, as you’d expect:
It's time to vote for your @BollingerUK player of the match 🌹#GuinnessSixNations #ITAvENG
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
If you missed it - here is Paul Rees’ report from earlier today, after Scotland consigned Wales to a fifth straight defeat:
There’s a lot of speculation on Twitter that Boris Johnson’s press conference has been delayed because he was watching the rugby. Honesty is the best policy, Boris, is it true?
Here’s a clip of Jamie George’s try, when our referee got rather mixed up about where the try line actually was:
Jamie George dots down on his 50th appearance for England 🌹#ITAvENG #GuinnessSixNations pic.twitter.com/mHBDxRUKjE
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
Owen Farrell speaks to ITV: “We’ve done our job, really ... we’ll wait and see now. We started the game well, at the start ... I thought we went at them. But there was a large chunk of the first half when we couldn’t get our hands on the ball, and we couldn’t get our game on the field, but that’s what international rugby is like sometimes ... we went in at half-time and we got the job done in the end. We’ll watch the game [in Paris] and we’ll see what happens.”
Updated
Clive Woodward: “You’ve got to say, Italy, second half, they just fell apart and England were far too strong. In the first half, they kicked the ball away too much ... it wasn’t a great game but they got the job done.”
Updated
Jonny Wilkinson on England’s efforts: “It’s a fair achievement, considering they haven’t had much rugby. At the end of the game, they still needed to pick up that bonus point, and they found a way to do it.”
Ben Youngs speaks to ITV: “It’s a nice milestone [reaching 100 caps for England] ... we spoke about it being a grinding-down process. We were camped on our own line, maybe that yellow card shook us up a little bit. We got there in the end.”
Youngs was excellent tonight, scoring two tries and creating plenty aside from that. His experience was essential at the times of the match when Italy were putting England under quite some pressure.
Updated
Full time! Italy 5-34 England
All over. England are now six better off, points-wise, than Ireland. So if Ireland beat France by seven points or more, they will be Six Nations champions. It was by no means a perfect display by England - and Italy played some excellent rugby. But England got the bonus point they needed to give themselves the best chance of being champions.
For France to win, they need a bonus point and a 32-point winning margin. A bonus-point win for Ireland would also do the job, of course, regardless of points difference.
Updated
80 + 2 mins: England think they are going to have a chance for more points, but a penalty is reversed for an illegal neck roll by Stuart.
80 mins: Slade kicks a penalty for touch and England will have one more chance for some points ...
Updated
75 min: Italy win a penalty. At this rate, England will be praying that France can beat Ireland, because they don’t have enough points on the board to take the title on points difference if Ireland win. Gaps are opening up in the Italian defence, though, and Jones’s men will hope to grab at least one more try.
Updated
72 min: Try! Italy 5-34 England (Slade)
Farrell puts a good grubber through, Ben Earl runs on to it, pops a pass up to Slade, who is half-tackled but manages to get over the line. Farrell hits the post again with a tough conversion.
Updated
67 min: Try! Italy 5-29 England (Curry)
That was a super bit of work by Curry. Youngs had made a dart towards the corner. The Italian defenders had stepped infield to cover and left the door open by the corner flag. Curry saw it, grabbed the ball and sprinted over. Really good finish - and that’s the bonus point for England! They have to keep searching for points though, to make it harder for Ireland in Paris later tonight. Farrell hits the post with the conversion.
Updated
66 min: Around halfway, England win a penalty in contact via Stuart, and they kick for touch in the left-hand corner. Youngs makes another sniping run ... and Curry is in!
63 min: Possession for Italy - they move through several phases in the England 22, but the visitors’ tackling and defensive shape remains solid. Will Stuart is on for England. Ferrari came on for Italy after half-time, replacing Fischetti.
Updated
62 min: Here’s a clip of Youngs’ second try just after half-time:
A second for the man of the moment 🌹#ITAvENG #GuinnessSixNations pic.twitter.com/5a1sH6bfU7
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
59 min: Ellis Genge is on for England, Mako Vunipola off. England have 20 minutes or so to find another try, which would secure a bonus point after two tries for Ben Youngs and one for Jamie George.
Updated
58 min: England concede another penalty, this time for Jonny May holding on after the tackle, and the Italians celebrate passionately yet again. A good attacking platform for Italy results, with a line-out a few metres from the England line.
Updated
55 min: The England replacement Ben Earl concedes a penalty for a no-arms tackle. Italy have a spell of possession in midfield, and then kick back to Furbank in the full-back position.
Updated
54 min: Ollie Thorley comes on for England, for his debut, Anthony Watson goes off. Ben Earl is on for Underhill permanently, following that earlier blood injury.
Updated
52 min: Try! Italy 5-24 England (George)
This is more like it. The referee initially got mixed up about where the try line is, but we got there in the end, and Jamie George has a try on his 50th appearance for England.
50 min: Italy cough up a penalty for coming in at the side. England are starting to fizz a little bit now ... Jamie George thinks he’s scored a try after a driving maul, the referee thinks not, but it seems the ref is confused by where the line actually is. It’s a try!
48 min: When you think back to that thrilling finale to the 2015 championship, when England and France were running in tries like it was going out of fashion, this is a very poor spectacle in comparison. Farrell kicks possession away again. It does seem slightly bizarre that England are kicking so much when they need four tries minimum, as Woodward pointed out at the break.
Updated
46 min: England have a scrum in midfield. They win the ball cleanly at the set-piece and appear to have the perfect opportunity to run the ball, but Slade chooses to kick.
Matteo Minozzi then clashes heads with Jonny May, in an accidental collision, and he goes off with blood streaming from his face. Guglielmo Palazzani comes on.
Updated
43 min: A quite frankly stupid hit by Tom Curry on Mattia Bellini in the air. Curry escapes by giving away just a penalty. That could easily have been a yellow card for the visitors when they had just started to make progress again. This remains a very spiky affair, with both teams fired up. Polledri will be coming back on in three minutes.
Updated
41 min: Try! Italy 5-17 England (Youngs)
A lovely sniping score by the England scrum-half. Jonny Hill did well to half charge down an Italian clearing kick. Itoje secured possession, Youngs grabbed the ball and glimpsed a gap - he skipped through it, beat the covering defender and flopped over. Perfect start for England as they hunt for this bonus point. Farrell adds the extras.
Updated
Second half kick-off!
Here we go. England will be desperate to start on the front foot.
Updated
Wilkinson: “You’ve got to get that composure back, you’ve got to accept what is, then you can get your feet on the ground and you can start moving. It’s a 40-minute game now, who cares what happened, it’s about what happens now.”
Woodward: “England have got to start playing properly. We’re a better team than them. There are times to throw some tea cups around, and that was a poor half by England.”
“The amount of ball we kicked away is crazy, considering the talent of this England team,” says Sir Clive.
“They’ve niggled England a bit now and England haven’t reacted too well, to be honest.”
Dallaglio asks: “Can Italy do that again for another 40 minutes?”
The studio pundits are now picking over that early England try, at which point, it looked like it might be a comfortable bonus-point win for Jones’s men.
Rusty is an understatement @LukeMcLaughlin. A bonus point seems a long way away but I'm sure we'll come out harder in the second half. It's the accuracy that's average though. It's cost us a good try at least so far. Unhappy Eddie.
— Guy Hornsby (@GuyHornsby) October 31, 2020
Updated
Half-time! Italy 5-10 England
It was all looking good for England early on, when a Ben Youngs try and an Owen Farrell penalty put them into a 10-0 lead after 13 minutes. But then some bad errors crept in - Kyle Sinckler spilled a pass which allowed Jake Polledri to score a superb try in the corner, and ever since then, Italy have looked the better side. Carlo Canna has been excellent for the Azzurri. England have lacked any kind of attacking continuity for 30 minutes, and Eddie Jones will doubtless have some harsh words at half-time. With Italy down to 14 men, with Polledri in the bin, they badly need to get busy in the opening minutes of the second half.
Updated
40 min: Italy stream down to the other end of the pitch, and Luca Morisi nearly has the ball down in-goal as he and Furbank charge on to a bouncing ball. They both miss it, but Jonny May touches down in goal, and it’s no try.
39 min: Yellow card! Jake Polledri
Italy’s try-scorer is in the sin bin for cynically spoiling England’s driving maul. England go for the try line again, but Italy win a penalty, and celebrate like they’ve just won the Six Nations, or maybe even the World Cup ...
Updated
38 min: England have an attacking line-out, and they get the drive on towards the line, but there’s a knock-on - but Polledri is sin-binned!
36 min: Ben Earl comes on, Underhill goes off with that blood injury. Can England find something positive to take into half-time? Italy have been the better team since that very positive opening for Eddie Jones’s men.
Updated
34 min: Italy shove a maul over the try line! But the referee rules that it’s held up, and Italy will now have a five-metre scrum. England are under tonnes of pressure ... but then they win a scrum penalty thanks to a particularly big shove by Sinckler. Italy lose their cool having been worked over at the scrum, and it’s another 10 metres. Slade takes the kick for touch, and England have relieved the pressure.
Updated
33 min: Jonny Hill is back on from the sin bin and we are 15 v 15 again. Italy are deep in English territory, they’ve already had one line-out and driving maul, and now they have an opportunity to have another go.
31 min: Again it’s Italian progress down the left wing - a lovely step inside and a surge by Mattia Bellini, then it’s hacked forward by an Italian boot, and Jonny May has to tidy things up at the back. Now there’s a scuffle involving Maro Itoje, Tom Curry and several others. Italy kick a penalty for touch, they have a line-out in a dangerous spot as far as England are concerned.
29 min: Italy make more inroads down that left wing, with Canna in the middle of the action again. Sam Underhill requires some treatment for a blood injury. We have reached the half-hour mark, and as things stand right now, England are going to have a job to register the bonus-point win that they almost certainly require to be champions.
27 min: The England full-back George Furbank strikes a brilliant kick for touch from inside England’s own 22, giving his team some field position, halfway inside Italian territory. Italy get the line-out right, and then there’s an error by Joseph out on England’s right, knocking it on. We thought England might look a bit ring-rusty, and after that bright start, some errors are now creeping in. Eddie Jones won’t be happy with this lack of precision.
Updated
23 min: Yellow card! Jonny Hill
The Italy wing Edoardo Padovani was smashed by the Exeter man Jonny Hill, following an initial hit by Sam Underhill, and the TMO and referee decide together that it’s a penalty and yellow card. “You have to be in control of your own body when you go into a tackle,” says Flatman on comms. Padovani goes off for a concussion check. A disappointing start to Hill’s England career, that is for sure. After a very solid start, during which they scored 10 unanswered points, England are now wobbling and they are a man down to boot. Italy are visibly growing into this game.
Updated
22 min: The TMO is looking at a tackle by Jonny Hill, which replays suggest was a bit high. “For me it’s a penalty and yellow card,” says referee Pascal Gauzčre.
Updated
Try! 18 min: Italy 5-10 England
That is a sensational finish by the Gloucester man, running the ball in powerfully in the corner after England coughed up possession and left themselves exposed. Maro Itoje had pulled off a brilliant turnover on England’s right, but Kyle Sinckler then spilled a pass which bounced kindly for Carlo Canna, who snatched it, off-loads to Polledri, and he smashed over in the corner despite a desperate attempt to knock him into touch by Henry Slade. Wonderful score. The conversion is missed. Game on!
Updated
16 min: Jonny May tries to run on to a grubber kick by Youngs, but he can’t gather it and knocks it on.
15 min: All the early signs are that England’s power and precision is going to be far too much for Italy, but what is the winning margin going to be, and will it be enough to win the title?
@LukeMcLaughlin England could easily run in a bakers dozen here today doesn’t matter that they didn’t play last week they’ve got the personnel & power to do it.
— John McEnerney (@MackerOnTheMed) October 31, 2020
Updated
13 min: Penalty! Italy 0-10 England (Farrell)
That spell of English pressure and another visit to the 22 brings points, but instead of kicking the penalty for the corner, Farrell strokes it through the posts for a three-pointer.
Updated
11 min: England now have another scrum, inside the Italian 22. They move it through the hands out to the right, via Ben Youngs, then come back the same way, England’s powerful carriers causing plenty of problems for Italy’s defenders with short carries, grabbing a metre here or there.
9 min: Italy have their first put-in at a scrum now, but England demolish their opposition again up front, and England win the put-in. The referee Pascal Gauzčre is doing plenty of talking, and trying to establish the terms of engagement for these set-pieces.
Updated
5 min: Try! Italy 0-7 England (Youngs)
Simple stuff, Farrell makes a break straight down the middle thanks to a lovely little pass with soft hands by Mako Vunipola, that allows the fly-half to ghost straight through the defensive line. Youngs is then on his inside shoulder, Farrell makes a regulation pass, and Youngs runs it in under the posts, a nice way to mark his 100th cap. England are up and running, they have started really well.
Updated
3 min: The young Italian fly-half, Paolo Garbisi, makes a good catch and takes a mark in the Italian 22. Farrell then has another chance to kick, and England make headway into the red zone ... Tom Curry charges down a Garbisi kick, and it squirts out in the in-goal area, with Curry trying to chase it down.
Updated
2 min: England win a penalty at the first scrum of the match. Farrell kicks for touch, into the Italian half. “A nice start for England’s front eight,” says David Flatman on commentary.
First half kick-off!
Billy Vunipola fields Italy’s kick-off and runs it back a few metres. Matteo Minozzi then immediately makes an impressive catch, after England kick, and makes a few metres ...
Updated
Time for the national anthems, in front of an all-but empty Stadio Olimpico. Kick-off is imminent. Can England get the bonus point? Italy belt out their anthem with plenty of passion. They look fired up for this, and you can only imagine they will be very keen to show that they are not here today just to roll over and let England run in as many tries as they like.
Updated
Don’t forget - you can contact me with your thoughts on the match - email or tweet @LukeMcLaughlin
Before we start - here is Paul Rees’ match report from Scotland’s win against Wales:
Dallaglio: “England will break it into 20-minute blocks. If they play well at the start they’ll get their reward in the third and fourth quarters.”
Woodward: “I’m not with you, I think they should start really quickly, Italy will struggle with the sheer pace they play the game at.”
Woodward also said, a couple of minutes ago, that he feels Slade’s best position is at No 13, that he is ‘world-class’ in that position and he shouldn’t be playing 12.
Two landmark appearances for England today: It’s the hooker Jamie George’s 50th cap:
5️⃣0️⃣ 🌹
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
A special day for @J_George2 today, congratulations Jamie 👏 pic.twitter.com/35GqIGQhSs
And the scrum-half Ben Youngs’ 100th:
A special pair of boots to celebrate a special match for @benyoungs09 1️⃣0️⃣0️⃣@adidasUK #ITAvENG pic.twitter.com/T3WxuRZtuS
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
If you missed it, the All Blacks put 43 points on Australia in Sydney today - the 43-5 victory was a record scoreline as they claimed the Bledisloe Cup:
Eddie Jones on how he took the Barbarians match cancellation: “Look, we just got on with it, mate. I went upstairs and scribbled on a bit of paper and within 30 minutes we were on to ‘Plan B’. These things happen, we don’t want them to happen but they do, and we just get on with it.”
Updated
Sir Clive Woodward is upbeat on Italy’s ability - but less so on those words of Franco Smith: “I think Italy will go a lot better than people expect today. But I don’t like Franco Smith saying “We are on a three-year project” ... your mindset has got to be this game. The coach should say: “It’s today or never.” I don’t expect them to win, but I think they can cause England some problems. International sport is not about the future, it’s about the next game, and I think they can give it a real go.”
Updated
The Italy head coach, Franco Smith, talks to ITV, starting off with a word about the returning full-back Matteo Minozzi: “He’s full of confidence, he is coming off a very good Premiership, he’s played a lot of rugby compared to some of the other guys, so it’s important for him to bring some of that energy and winning culture ...
“We said we’re at the start of the process, with a lot of new young guys coming in ... they are in a place to learn against the best in the world today. We definitely want to improve, we want to play our brand, we want to show we can play with the ball, the surface is quick and it’s a good evening. I know they would like to play - and so do we. Hopefully our ball retention will be better.”
Updated
Ugo Monye asks the question - if England, Ireland and France are all going to throw caution to the wind today and go all-out for bonus-point wins, why don’t we see that every week?
And here is Gerard Meagher: “To demonstrate how much has changed since England last played nearly eight months ago, they will run out at an empty Stadio Olimpico, barring the 400 or so people working at the venue. The players will be obliged to stand at least one metre apart for the socially distanced national anthems, before which they will be given the opportunity to make an anti-racism gesture. The England squad have been given the personal choice as to whether they wish to take a knee or mark the moment in some other way.”
Time for some pre-match reading. Here is Robert Kitson’s preview of what could be a thrilling finish to this season’s Six Nations:
Our host Mark Pougatch asks Jonny Wilkinson about Eddie Jones’ comments during the week in which he compared fly-halves to sushi chefs.
“You have to go on a journey, and it takes a lot of time and effort,” says Wilkinson. “You come to a place of effortlessness that was there at the beginning ... you realise at the end that you had it at the start. You start off grafting, and you end as a ‘genius’ ... to see gaps, to maintain your agility, not to become bogged down by it. You see that in the best ... it’s a filter, that effortlessness, it’s learning to let go.”
That’s getting pretty deep for the first five minutes of the programme, but I think I can see what he’s getting at.
Updated
Jonny Wilkinson, Sir Clive Woodward and Lawrence Dallaglio are in the ITV studio to offer their expertise.
“Eddie Jones sometimes baffles people with his selections,” says Dallaglio. “But he knows how he wants to play a game of rugby and his record speaks for itself ... He is successful, it’s got a nice feel about it this side, there are 635 caps out there, and they need that because England haven’t played together for a long time.”
Breaking news: Scotland have beaten Wales, 14-10. That’s five defeats in a row for Wales now.
Updated
Teams
The hosts Italy have made one change from the team that lost in Dublin last week, with Matteo Minozzi coming in at full-back.
For England, the scrum-half Ben Youngs wins his 100th cap. Exeter’s Jonny Hill makes his debut at lock after a stellar domestic season, with his club mate Henry Slade lining up at No 12, in the centre alongside Jonathan Joseph. Owen Farrell is back at No 10.
Italy
15-Matteo Minozzi, 14-Edoardo Padovani, 13-Luca Morisi, 12-Carlo Canna, 11-Mattia Bellini, 10-Paolo Garbisi, 9-Marcello Violi, 1-Danilo Fischetti, 2-Luca Bigi, 3-Giosue Zilocchi, 4-Marco Lazzaroni, 5-Niccolo Cannone, 6-Sebastian Negri, 7-Braam Steyn, 8-Jake Polledri. Replacements: 16-Gianmarco Lucchesi, 17-Simone Ferrari, 18-Pietro Ceccarelli, 19-David Sisi, 20-Johan Meyer, 21-Maxime Mbanda, 22-Guglielmo Palazzani, 23-Federico Mori
England
15-George Furbank, 14-Anthony Watson, 13-Jonathan Joseph, 12-Henry Slade, 11-Jonny May, 10-Owen Farrell, 9-Ben Youngs, 1-Mako Vunipola, 2-Jamie George, 3-Kyle Sinckler, 4-Maro Itoje, 5-Jonny Hill, 6-Tom Curry, 7-Sam Underhill, 8-Billy Vunipola. Replacements: 16-Tom Dunn, 17-Ellis Genge, 18-Will Stuart, 19-Charlie Ewels, 20-Ben Earl, 21-Dan Robson, 22-Ollie Lawrence, 23-Ollie Thorley
Referee: Pascal Gauzčre
Your side to face Italy 🏴🇮🇹
— England Rugby (@EnglandRugby) October 31, 2020
Watch live on ITV with kick off from 16:45 GMT 🌹#ITAvENG #GuinnessSixNations pic.twitter.com/iIPel1MUOJ
Updated
Preamble
What we know for sure is that the destiny of the Six Nations championship will be decided tonight. But a number of potential outcomes remain on the table, with England, France and Ireland all in with a chance of lifting the title at the end of this singular campaign.
England are in Rome with a multi-faceted mission: try to set aside all the recent upheaval and the Barbarians shambles, disregard the known unknowns over what may unfold when France host Ireland in Paris tonight, incorporate several new faces into the matchday 23, and defeat Italy as handsomely as possible. Preferably with an attacking bonus point. Easy, right?
Eddie Jones and his side have come a long way since the crushing disappointment of losing the World Cup final to South Africa, just under a year ago. The Saracens salary cap affair would have been enough disruption for any international coach to deal with in any given year: but as that news emerged in January, Covid-19 was already spreading across the globe, and it would not be long before professional sport would be shut down completely. For England, securing the title would be a satisfying way to end a bizarre and demanding Six Nations, and the £5m prize money would certainly be welcomed by the RFU, now under serious financial strain just like every other union.
Mathematically speaking at least, if Ireland muster up a bonus-point win against France later, they will be champions regardless and England’s efforts today will be irrelevant. But given the impressive way France dispatched Wales last weekend, that particular outcome seems unlikely. If England win with a bonus point and Ireland fail to beat France, England are champions - unless France get a bonus point themselves and their winning margin is at least two points more than England. It will also come down to points difference if England take a bonus-point win and Ireland do not - but England would need 24 points more than the Irish in their margin of victory.
Simply put, England need to win and win well at the Stadio Olimpico, take a hot shower, and settle down in front of a TV to watch what happens in Paris. Team news, pre-match reading and much more coming up ...
Updated