Steve Borthwick has launched a passionate defence of referees, as have a host of his counterparts, after Rassie Erasmus’s astonishing tirade in which he questioned whether match officials were “match-fixing”.
Borthwick refused to specifically address, let alone condemn, Erasmus’s remarkable claims that the Italian referee Andrea Piardi and his assistants had shown France leniency in their victory over South Africa, suggesting they had “manipulated the game”.
The England head coach did, however, express “100% confidence” that match officials “do the very best they can” and urged that referees are treated with respect. Two years ago, the Guardian revealed how the Rugby Football Union was increasing sanctions for match officials abuse after 49% of referees surveyed revealed they had been targeted. The RFU referee Christophe Ridley, who is a regular visitor to England’s training camp, has the unenviable task of officiating South Africa’s clash with Ireland but Borthwick backed him to “do a brilliant job” amid the increased scrutiny.
Borthwick’s comments came as France’s head coach, Fabien Galthié, said he “hurts rugby” if he criticises match officials while the All Blacks’ Dave Rennie expressed sympathy for referees who have a “pretty busy life at the moment”. Eddie Jones acknowledged that Erasmus, who has been banned for six matches by World Rugby, had “overstepped the mark”.
“I’m not going to comment on another coach or what another coach has done,” said Borthwick, after recalling a host of frontline stars for Saturday’s clash with the All Blacks. “What I will say is that match officials have a really tough job. It’s a really challenging job that match officials have. I have absolute 100% confidence and faith that every match official in every game tries to do the very best they can. And I think they deserve enormous respect. In rugby, you respect the match officials; any player I coach, we expect the same.
“In the values of our game, respect is clearly central to that. I talked about my schoolteacher and how you refer to the referee, you call the referee ‘Sir’. And I still do now, it has been a habit for so many years, you call the referee ‘Sir’. It doesn’t mean we always agree but you get on with it. That is what you do in rugby. I will be absolutely clear, I am not talking about any other coach and not commenting on anyone else’s behaviour, I am talking about me.”
England: G Furbank (Harlequins); T Freeman (Northampton Saints), H Slade (Exeter Chiefs), S Atkinson (Gloucester Rugby), W Joseph (Gloucester Rugby); F Smith (Northampton Saints), J van Poortvliet (Leicester Tigers); F Baxter (Harlequins), J George (Saracens), J Heyes (Leicester Tigers), M Itoje (Saracens, capt), A Coles (Northampton Saints), O Chessum (Leicester Tigers), B Curry (Sale Sharks), B Earl (Saracens).
Replacements: L Cowan-Dickie (Sale Sharks), E Genge (Bristol Bears), W Stuart (Bath Rugby), G Martin (Saracens), G Fisilau (Exeter Chiefs), H Pollock (Northampton Saints), B Spencer (Bath Rugby), M Smith (Harlequins).
New Zealand: Beauden Barrett; Will Jordan, Anton Lienert-Brown, Jordie Barrett, Josh Moorby; Damian McKenzie, Cam Roigard; Wallace Sititi, Peter Lakai, Tupou Vaa’i; Fabian Holland, Scott Barrett; Fletcher Newell, Codie Taylor (capt), Ethan de Groot.
Replacements: Asafo Aumua, George Bower, Pasilio Tosi, Anton Segner, Leicester Fainga’anuku, Cortez Ratima, Richie Mo’unga, Rieko Ioane
The closest Borthwick came to criticising Erasmus was when discussing his front-row configuration against New Zealand on Saturday, with a thinly veiled dig at the South African’s tendency to switch his three starters shortly before kick-off. Against France, Erasmus changed his lineup so late that his starting front row wore numbers 16, 17 and 18. “Just to be clear here, there will be no changes in the warmup, of who’s going to start, who’s going to finish,” said Borthwick. “1-2-3 will start the game.”
Galthié, meanwhile, spoke of a “responsibility” for someone in his position with France on course to book their place in the Nations Championship final if they beat Argentina with a bonus point. They could potentially face South Africa again at Twickenham next weekend.
“As a coach, I have a responsibility towards the fans, towards the grassroots coaches, towards the players,” he said. “I have a duty and a responsibility towards the world of rugby and towards World Rugby. I think that when you are a national coach, you are responsible for your words, responsible for your behaviour. Without a referee, there is no rugby. There is no rugby for children, there is no education, we have to respect the rules.
“As a national coach, I have to take care of refereeing. If I don’t take care of my words when it comes to refereeing, then I hurt rugby, I hurt the supporters, I hurt our opponents. What we learn first in our sport is fair play. What is fair play? We shake hands with the opponent and make a date for the next match. But the first person whose hand we shake before we leave the pitch is the referee.”
Borthwick has called on the cavalry with George Furbank, Ollie Chessum and Seb Atkinson returning to the England side to face the All Blacks. As England seek to clinch back-to-back victories over New Zealand for the first time since 2003, the head coach has named the same side that beat Australia, barring Will Joseph’s selection in the absence of Immanuel Feyi-Waboso.
As reported by the Guardian, Borthwick has rewarded Joseph after the 24-year-old scored five tries on his first Twickenham start in the demolition of Japan last Saturday. The Gloucester flyer switches to the left wing with Tommy Freeman coming back on to the right, meaning he will go head-to-head with New Zealand’s all-time top try-scorer, Will Jordan, who has been named to start by the All Blacks. In total, Borthwick has made nine personnel changes to the side that thumped Japan.
New Zealand have made eight changes to the side that lost to Wales last Saturday, with Jordan returning from a hamstring injury and Codie Taylor returning as captain. Beauden Barrett will become the fourth player in rugby history to make 150 Test appearances having been named at full-back while Damian McKenzie comes back into the side at fly-half.